££
Sicilian Restaurants in New York City
Ristorante Il Melograno
Ristorante Il Melograno is a Sicilian restaurant located on West 51 Street. They serve Italian food the way it should be.
Forno Siciliano
Forno Siciliano is a family-owned Sicilian restaurant and pizza place that has been serving customers with the freshest ingredients for over 20 years. They are known for their homemade fresh mozzarella and original brick oven pizzas.
Gino's Pizzeria
Gino's Pizzeria, located on Forest Avenue, is a family-owned pizza place and Sicilian restaurant that prioritizes customer satisfaction and service.
Concrete Brooklyn
Located in Bedstuy, Concrete Brooklyn Brooklyn is a casual dining Sicilian eatery and burger restaurant that also functions as a bar, music and event venue, and art space.
Full list of Sicilian Restaurants
Other cuisines
Abruzzo Acehnese Afghani African American Arabian Argentinian Armenian Asian Fusion Asian Australian Austrian Azerbaijani Balinese Bar & Grill Barbecue Basilicata Basque Bavarian Beer Bar Beer garden Belarusian Belgian Bengali/Bangladeshi Bolivian Bossam/Jokbal Brazilian Breakfast & brunch British Buffet Bunsik Burger Burmese Cafe Cafeteria Cajun & Creole Cambodian Canadian Cantonese Caribbean Caterer Chicken Joint Chilean Chinese Coffee shop Colombian Comfort Food Continental Crêperie Cuban Cupcake Shop Czech Deli Dessert Shop Dhaba Dim sum Diner Dominican Donburi Donut Shop Dosa Drive In Eastern European Ecuadorian Egyptian Ethiopian European Family style Fast food Filipino Fish & Chips Fondue Food Delivery Service Food stall Food Truck French Frozen Yogurt Shop Fujian Gastropub Gelato Shop Georgian German Gluten-Free Greek Guatemalan Haitian Halal Hawaiian Health Food Himalayan Honduran Hong Kong Hot Dog Joint Hot Pot Hunan Hungarian Ice Cream Shop Indian Chinese Indian Indo Chinese Indonesian Irish Pub Irish Israeli Italian Jain Jamaican Japanese Jiangsu Jiangxi Kaiseki Kashmiri Kebab Shop Kerala Korean Kosher Kushikatsu Latin American Lebanese Live & raw food Malaysian Mediterranean Mexican Middle Eastern Modern European Molecular Gastronomy Moroccan Neapolitan Nepalese New American Nicaraguan Nigerian Noodle House North Indian Okonomiyaki Pakistani Panamanian Paraguayan Persian/Iranian Peruvian Pho Pizza Place Poke Polish Polynesian Portuguese Pub Puerto Rican Punjabi Rajasthani Ramen Restaurant /Cafe Roman Romanian Russian Salad Bar Salvadoran Sandwich shop Sardinian Scandinavian Seafood Senegalese Shabu Shabu Shanghainese Singaporean Smoothie & Juice Bar Soba Soul Food Soup South African South Indian South Tyrolean Southern Southwestern Spanish Sri Lankan Steakhouse Sushi Swiss Syrian Szechuan/Sichuan Taco Taiwanese Takoyaki Tapas Bar & Restaurant Tea room Tempura Teppanyaki Tex-mex Thai Theme Tonkatsu Trentino Alto Adige Trinidadian Turkish Tuscan Udon Ukrainian Uruguayan Uttar Pradesh Uzbek Vegetarian/Vegan Venezuelan Vietnamese Yakiniku Yakitori YunnanWhat people say
When it comes to Italian cuisine, Sicilian food is often overlooked. But in New York City, Sicilian restaurants are gaining popularity and rave reviews. From traditional dishes to modern twists on classic recipes, there’s something for everyone.
One of the most highly recommended Sicilian restaurants in New York is L'Artusi. Located in the West Village, this restaurant offers a modern take on traditional Sicilian dishes. Visitors rave about their pasta dishes, especially the spaghetti with bottarga and breadcrumbs. Prices range from moderate to expensive, with entrees starting at $25.
For a more budget-friendly option, locals recommend Joe's Pizza in Greenwich Village. Known for their classic Sicilian-style pizza, Joe's has been a staple in the neighborhood for over 40 years. Prices are affordable, with a large slice of pizza starting at just $3.
If you’re looking for a more upscale dining experience, Il Buco Alimentari e Vineria in NoHo is a must-visit. The restaurant features an open kitchen and serves rustic Italian cuisine, including several Sicilian dishes. Prices are on the higher side, with entrees starting at $30.
For those looking for Michelin-starred Sicilian cuisine, La Capannina in Staten Island is the only restaurant in the city to receive such an honor. The restaurant serves traditional dishes like caponata and pasta con le sarde (pasta with sardines). Prices are on the higher side, with entrees ranging from $35 to $55.
When it comes to where locals and tourists go, it really depends on what you’re looking for. Tourists often flock to famous spots like Eataly or Carbone, while locals tend to seek out more authentic experiences. However, all of the recommended restaurants mentioned above attract both locals and visitors alike.
In terms of whether New York is a good place for Sicilian cuisine, the answer is a resounding yes. With a large Italian-American population, the city has a deep appreciation for all types of Italian food. And with the rise in popularity of Sicilian restaurants in recent years, it’s clear that New Yorkers are embracing this unique cuisine.
In conclusion, if you’re looking for delicious Sicilian food in New York City, there are plenty of options to choose from. Whether you’re on a budget or looking to splurge, there’s a restaurant that will satisfy your cravings. Whether you’re a local or a tourist, it’s clear that Sicilian cuisine is quickly becoming a must-try in the city that never sleeps.