££
Sicilian Restaurants in Manhattan, New York
Ristorante Il Melograno
A popular Sicilian restaurant located on West 51 Street, Ristorante Il Melograno offers authentic Italian cuisine that is sure to satisfy any craving.
Concrete Brooklyn
Located in Bedstuy, Concrete Brooklyn is a unique eatery that combines Sicilian and American staples with a casual dining experience. Featuring a bar, music and event venue, and art, this restaurant is perfect for those looking for something different.
Experience the flavors of Sicily in Manhattan with these top-rated restaurants.
Full list of Sicilian Restaurants
Top 10 cuisines
The most popular cuisines in Manhattan are:
Italian American Mexican Sushi Vegetarian/Vegan FrenchAll other cuisines
Abruzzo African American Argentinian Asian Fusion Asian Australian Austrian Bar & Grill Barbecue Basilicata Basque Beer Bar Beer garden Belgian Bossam/Jokbal Brazilian Breakfast & brunch British Burger Cafe Cafeteria Cajun & Creole Cambodian Cantonese Caribbean Caterer Chicken Joint Chinese Coffee shop Colombian Comfort Food Continental Crêperie Cuban Cupcake Shop Deli Dessert Shop Dim sum Diner Dominican Donburi Donut Shop Drive In Eastern European Ecuadorian Egyptian Ethiopian European Family style Fast food Filipino Fish & Chips Fondue Food Delivery Service Food stall Food Truck French Frozen Yogurt Shop Gastropub Gelato Shop Georgian German Gluten-Free Greek Guatemalan Haitian Halal Hawaiian Health Food Hot Dog Joint Hot Pot Hunan Ice Cream Shop Indian Indonesian Irish Pub Irish Israeli Italian Jain Jamaican Japanese Kaiseki Kebab Shop Korean Kosher Latin American Lebanese Live & raw food Malaysian Mediterranean Mexican Middle Eastern Modern European Moroccan New American Noodle House North Indian Pakistani Persian/Iranian Peruvian Pho Pizza Place Poke Polish Portuguese Pub Puerto Rican Ramen Restaurant Russian Salad Bar Sandwich shop Seafood Senegalese Shanghainese Sicilian Singaporean Smoothie & Juice Bar Soul Food Soup South African South Indian Southern Southwestern Spanish Sri Lankan Steakhouse Sushi Swiss Szechuan/Sichuan Taco Taiwanese Tapas Bar & Restaurant Tea room Tex-mex Thai Theme Tonkatsu Turkish Tuscan Udon Ukrainian Uzbek Vegetarian/Vegan Venezuelan Vietnamese Yakiniku YakitoriWhat people say
Manhattan is known for its diverse and vibrant food scene, and Sicilian cuisine is no exception. With its unique blend of Italian and Mediterranean flavors, Sicilian cuisine has gained popularity among locals and tourists alike. If you are looking for a taste of Sicily in Manhattan, here are some recommended restaurants that have received good reviews and comments.
One of the top-rated Sicilian restaurants in Manhattan is Eolo. Located in Chelsea, Eolo offers traditional Sicilian dishes with a modern twist. The restaurant's menu includes arancini, pasta alla Norma, and cassata cake. Prices are on the higher side, with entrees ranging from $20 to $40.
Another popular option is Cacio e Vino, located in the Lower East Side. This rustic Italian restaurant offers a variety of Sicilian dishes, including caponata, pasta con le sarde, and cannoli for dessert. Prices are more affordable, with entrees ranging from $15 to $25.
For those looking for a more casual dining experience, Joe & Pat's Pizzeria is a must-visit. This Staten Island-based pizzeria has opened a second location in the East Village of Manhattan, offering delicious thin-crust pizza and other Sicilian specialties such as rice balls (arancini), panelle (chickpea fritters), and cannoli. Prices are relatively cheap, with pizzas starting at $16.
Apart from these restaurants, there are several other options worth exploring, such as Casa Nonna, L'Artusi, and Il Posto Accanto. It's always best to check online reviews and comments before visiting any restaurant to get an idea of the menu, prices, and overall dining experience.
In terms of where locals and tourists go for Sicilian cuisine in Manhattan, it really depends on personal preferences. Some may prefer the trendy ambiance of Eolo or Casa Nonna while others may prefer the authentic feel of Joe & Pat's or Cacio e Vino.
Overall, if you are looking for a taste of Sicilian cuisine in Manhattan, there are plenty of options to choose from. Whether you're on a budget or willing to splurge, there is something for everyone.