££
Italian Restaurants in Staten Island, New York
Brothers Pizza
A pizza place and Italian restaurant located on Port Richmond Avenue, Brothers Pizza advertises itself as "you tried the rest...now try the best."
Portobello Cafe
Located on Hylan Boulevard, Portobello Cafe is a family-style restaurant and cafe that serves Italian cuisine.
Jimmy Max
Jimmy max of Westerleigh Restaurant & Bar is an Italian restaurant, pizzeria, and bar that offers delivery within a 2.5 mile radius of its location on 280 Watchogue Rd. Larger catering orders can be delivered island-wide.
Nucci's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
Nucci's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria serves abundant portions of pasta, chicken, veal, seafood, and pizza. They offer delivery and specialized menus for holidays.
Full list of Italian Restaurants
£££
What people say
If you're in the Staten Island borough of New York and craving Italian cuisine, you're in luck. The area offers a plethora of Italian restaurants to choose from, and online reviews and comments can help guide you to the best spots.
According to locals, one of the must-visit Italian restaurants in Staten Island is Angelina's Ristorante. Located on Hylan Boulevard, this restaurant offers authentic Italian dishes with impeccable service. Their seafood pasta dishes come highly recommended, as well as their tiramisu for dessert.
Another favorite among locals is Trattoria Romana, located on Richmond Avenue. This restaurant offers a cozy ambiance with an extensive wine list to accompany their delicious Italian cuisine. Their breaded veal chop and pappardelle bolognese are highly praised dishes.
For tourists, Enoteca Maria is a unique spot that offers rotating menus featuring dishes from different Italian regions prepared by nonnas (grandmothers) from those regions. Customers rave about the welcoming atmosphere and delicious homemade meals.
When it comes to prices, most Italian restaurants in Staten Island fall within the moderate to high price range. However, many customers believe that the quality of the food and service at these restaurants justifies the cost.
Overall, Staten Island is home to many outstanding Italian restaurants that are worth trying. Before making your decision, be sure to check out online reviews and comments to help guide you to the best dining experience possible.
Top 10 cuisines
The most popular cuisines in Staten Island are:
Italian American Mexican Sushi Seafood Health Food