Rustic Pizza & Pasteria

Rustic Pizza & Pasteria Rustic Pizza & Pasteria is an authentic Italian restaurant and pizza place located on Lincoln Avenue in Staten Island, NY. They offer a variety of well-crafted pizzas and pastas, including Classic Meatballs & Marinara with Whipped Ricotta, Shrimp & Lobster Ravioli, and 6 Cheese Ravioli. With their simple yet delicious Caprese salad and excellent pasta choices on the menu, this restaurant is perfect for any Italian food lover. Call them at 212-425-2623 to place your order or visit their website at www.RusticPizzaPasteria.com.

Recent social media posts

09/07/2026
Your neighborhood spot for good food, familiar faces, and the kind of nights you’ll want to do all over again. 🍷🍴Pull up...
09/02/2026

Your neighborhood spot for good food, familiar faces, and the kind of nights you’ll want to do all over again. 🍷🍴

Pull up a chair and join us at Rustic. 🤎

Maybe 🤔 a nice pasta dish? 😏
08/18/2026

Maybe 🤔 a nice pasta dish? 😏

The perfect spot to gather the whole crew. 🍕❤️ Big tables, rustic vibes, and plenty of room for family, friends, and a w...
08/15/2026

The perfect spot to gather the whole crew. 🍕❤️ Big tables, rustic vibes, and plenty of room for family, friends, and a whole lot of pizza. Who are you bringing to the table? 🍻

🍷🇮🇹 A Taste of Italy is coming to Rustic Pizza & Pasteria!Join us Tuesday, August 25 at 7PM for a special family-style W...
08/12/2026

🍷🇮🇹 A Taste of Italy is coming to Rustic Pizza & Pasteria!

Join us Tuesday, August 25 at 7PM for a special family-style Wine Paired Dinner featuring wines from Q1 Wines and a menu packed with Italian favorites. 🍕🍝

Enjoy two delicious courses paired with Le Merline Bianco & Rosso, followed by an indulgent dessert trio featuring Pistachio Cannoli, Mini Cookie Butter Calzone & Tiramisu. ✨

🍷 Taste of Italy Wine Paired Dinner
📅 Tuesday, August 25 | 7PM
💵 $49.95 per person + tax & gratuity
📍 Rustic Pizza & Pasteria

Seats are limited—reserve yours now at the link in our bio! 🇮🇹🍷

RusticPizza ItalianFood WineLovers DinnerEvent FoodAndWine

08/12/2026

Some guests leave a lasting impression on us, and this is one we feel especially honored to share. ❤️

This reel captures the first visit to Rustic Pizza & Pasteria from the grandfather of a member of our team, a place that would go on to become one of his favorite restaurants. From his warmth and personality to his unforgettable sense of humor (especially his reaction to our “minchia” sign), this is a memory we’re grateful was captured.

Today, we share it in loving memory of a very special man and in celebration of the laughter, stories, and moments that live on through those who loved him.

It was a privilege to welcome him to our table. May his memory always be a blessing. ❤️

THIS WEEKS SPECIALS LINE UPHERE AT RUSTIC! ✨Swipe left! Rustic Oyster Bull Shooter Housemade Pappardelle Pasta - Lobster...
08/05/2026

THIS WEEKS SPECIALS LINE UP
HERE AT RUSTIC! ✨Swipe left!

Rustic Oyster Bull Shooter

Housemade Pappardelle Pasta - Lobster Meat, Sauteed Shrimp, Cherry Peppers, Creamy Pink Sauce, Sundried Tomato

Pork Osso Bucco

Chef’s Special Alert 🚨 Pork Osso Bucco!
08/01/2026

Chef’s Special Alert 🚨 Pork Osso Bucco!

07/21/2026

We’re doing our best. 🤣

A little something special is waiting for you at Rustic. ✨Our latest feature is creamy burrata, savory prosciutto, green...
07/14/2026

A little something special is waiting for you at Rustic. ✨
Our latest feature is creamy burrata, savory prosciutto, green olives, roasted peppers, and finished with a drizzle of rich balsamic glaze. Every bite is the perfect balance of fresh, salty, and sweet.

Available for a limited time

07/10/2026

We’re more than just your neighborhood pizzeria, we’re the place where every occasion comes together. 🍕✨

Meet friends for happy hour at the bar, celebrate birthdays, gather the family around the table, enjoy our fresh lobster specials, or simply stop by for your favorite pizza and a great meal.

No matter what brings you in, Rustic is here to make every visit feel like home. We can’t wait to welcome you! 🍻🦞❤️

Address

1789 Richmond Road
Staten Island, NY
10306

If you are using public transport, take the train or bus to Lincoln Avenue station and then walk a few blocks northwards. Alternatively, if you're driving, take Lincoln Avenue and turn at the corner of the gas station. The restaurant is located a few blocks down on the right-hand side. Parking is available along the street as well as in a nearby parking garage.

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 10pm
Tuesday 11am - 10pm
Wednesday 11am - 10pm
Thursday 11am - 10pm
Friday 11am - 10:30pm
Saturday 11am - 10:30pm
Sunday 11am - 9pm

Telephone

+12124252623

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Rustic Pizza & Pasteria posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category

What people say

Italian restaurants are known for their delicious and authentic pizza and pasta dishes, and Rustic Pizza & Pasteria on Lincoln Avenue in New York is no exception. This cozy Italian restaurant offers a wide variety of flavorful and well-crafted pizzas, pastas, and other Italian dishes that are sure to satisfy any craving.

One of the standout features of Rustic Pizza & Pasteria is their customizable pasta menu. With over 8 different pasta options and a variety of sauces to choose from, diners can create their own perfect pasta dish. The Imported Rigatoni with Balsamic Cream Sauce is a must-try for anyone looking for a unique and delicious flavor combination.

In addition to their pasta offerings, Rustic Pizza & Pasteria also serves up some amazing personal pan pies. These individual-sized pizzas are perfect for those who want to try multiple flavors or just enjoy a pizza all to themselves.

For those with a sweet tooth, the house-made Tiramisu is not to be missed. And if you're feeling adventurous, give the Fried Ravioli a try - it's sure to be a hit.

Overall, Rustic Pizza & Pasteria is an excellent choice for anyone looking for authentic Italian cuisine in New York City. With delicious food and friendly service, this restaurant is definitely worth checking out.