Clicky

Rustic Pizza & Pasteria

Rustic Pizza & Pasteria Rustic Pizza & Pasteria is an authentic Italian restaurant and pizza place located on Lincoln Avenue in Staten Island, NY. They offer a variety of well-crafted pizzas and pastas, including Classic Meatballs & Marinara with Whipped Ricotta, Shrimp & Lobster Ravioli, and 6 Cheese Ravioli. With their simple yet delicious Caprese salad and excellent pasta choices on the menu, this restaurant is perfect for any Italian food lover. Call them at 212-425-2623 to place your order or visit their website at www.RusticPizzaPasteria.com.

Recent social media posts

🍕
05/30/2026

🍕

🏀🍕 Knicks fans, this one’s for you.Introducing The Brunson Special at Rustic Pizza & Pasteria.. the ultimate game day fe...
05/28/2026

🏀🍕 Knicks fans, this one’s for you.

Introducing The Brunson Special at Rustic Pizza & Pasteria.. the ultimate game day feast! 🔥

🍕 TWO 16” Cheese Pies
🍗 Dozen Wings
🧄 Not “Knots”
🥤 2 Liter Soda

ALL FOR JUST $49.95 🙌

Available on Knicks game days only for pickup & delivery!
Fuel the fans. Feed the team. 🧡💙

PizzaNight StatenIslandFood NYCPizza KnicksNation GameDayFuel PickupAndDelivery

05/22/2026

Think Rustic is just pizza? Think again. 🍕🍸

From handcrafted pastas and chef-inspired dishes to signature craft cocktails.. Rustic Pizza & Pasteria is your next dinner spot, perfect for family gatherings, parties, and hangout all in one.

Come have a seat at our bar, and see what everyone’s been missing. 🔥

Make your reservations for tonight! We’ll be here! 😉❤️
05/02/2026

Make your reservations for tonight! We’ll be here! 😉❤️

04/24/2026

Start the weekend the right way… at Rustic. 🍝🔥
Big flavors, strong pours, and a table that speaks for itself.
Whether you’re here for the pasta, the pizza, or the cocktails.. this is your sign to indulge a little.
Weekends were made for this.

04/13/2026

We know life doesn’t pause when you walk through our doors.. you’re carrying long days, big wins, quiet battles, and everything in between. Rustic is more than just a place to eat; it’s a place to land. A seat at the bar after work. A deep breath between moments. A drink that says, “you made it through today.”

Whatever kind of day you had, just know there’s a spot waiting for you. 🥃✨

04/08/2026

Looking for the perfect spot to celebrate? 🎉
Host your next get-together at Rustic Pizza & Pasteria!

Perfect for:
• 🍕 Pizza parties with friends
• 🎂 Birthday celebrations
• 👨‍👩‍👧‍👦 Family gatherings
• 🎓 Graduation parties
• 🥳 Team outings & work celebrations
• 💍 Engagement parties
• 🏈 Game day watch parties
• 🍕 Casual group dinners
• 🎄 Holiday get-togethers
• 🎉 Just-because parties

Great food, great vibes, and plenty of space to celebrate.
Let us handle the food, you bring the party!

04/07/2026

Pizza and Peroni never sounded better. 🍕🍺
It’s National Beer Day, and we’re celebrating the only way we know how, with cold pours and hot pies. Join us at Rustic Pizza & Pasteria and raise a glass with us!

Get those last minute orders in! Big table, full plates, zero stress 🍽️🐰 Feed the whole family this Easter with our Rust...
03/31/2026

Get those last minute orders in! Big table, full plates, zero stress 🍽️🐰 Feed the whole family this Easter with our Rustic catering special, for sharing and celebrating.

Sip happens… and today, we celebrate. 🍓✨Happy National Cocktail Day from Rustic! Meet your new obsession: the Strawberry...
03/24/2026

Sip happens… and today, we celebrate. 🍓✨

Happy National Cocktail Day from Rustic! Meet your new obsession: the Strawberry Limoncello Spritz. Bright, bubbly, and just the right amount of sweet.

Consider this your sign to clink glasses, soak up the vibes, and let the spritz do the talking. 🥂

Meet us at the bar 🍕🍷🍻  Happy Hour at Rustic Pizza & Pasteria means all your favorites.. ice-cold beers, perfect pours o...
03/17/2026

Meet us at the bar 🍕🍷🍻

Happy Hour at Rustic Pizza & Pasteria means all your favorites.. ice-cold beers, perfect pours of wine, and handcrafted cocktails paired with the flavors you crave.

Pull up a seat and let the good times pour. ✨

03/17/2026

Our “Not Knots” are the Glow up the Garlic Knot didn’t know it needed. Try them and you’ll know what we’re talking about 🍽️🤤

Seafood lovers won’t want to miss out on this weekly special! Join us for an Italian Seafood 🦞 boil. Available all day o...
03/12/2026

Seafood lovers won’t want to miss out on this weekly special! Join us for an Italian Seafood 🦞 boil. Available all day on Thursdays! ✨

It’s the holiday we’ve all been meat-ing for… 😏🍝Happy National Meatball Day from Rustic! Whether you like them classic, ...
03/09/2026

It’s the holiday we’ve all been meat-ing for… 😏🍝

Happy National Meatball Day from Rustic! Whether you like them classic, saucy, or piled high on pasta, today is your official excuse to indulge in the good stuff.

Round up your crew, grab a fork, and let’s get saucy. ❤️

📍 Dine in.
📦 Take out.
🍝 No regrets.

✨ Meatless Fridays are here ✨Celebrate Lent at Rustic with plenty of fresh seafood favorites from comforting classics to...
02/27/2026

✨ Meatless Fridays are here ✨

Celebrate Lent at Rustic with plenty of fresh seafood favorites from comforting classics to live lobster specials.. Join us every Friday and enjoy flavors you’ll look forward to all week. 🐟🍋

Check out our full list of menus on our website!

Hoping everyone stays safe and warm! ❄️
02/23/2026

Hoping everyone stays safe and warm! ❄️

02/16/2026

It’s Monday. Come Sip & Slice with us! 🍕

Freshly made. Always. ❤️
02/13/2026

Freshly made. Always. ❤️

It’s National Pizza Day! 🍕
02/09/2026

It’s National Pizza Day! 🍕

It’s Monday! Join us for our Sip & Slice special that includes a bottle of wine 🍷 and two pies 🍕 because who doesn’t lov...
02/09/2026

It’s Monday! Join us for our Sip & Slice special that includes a bottle of wine 🍷 and two pies 🍕 because who doesn’t love a sip and a slice?

Looking for Super Bowl plans? Come hang at the bar! We’ll have half price wings, apps, and beer all day along with $1 ba...
01/30/2026

Looking for Super Bowl plans? Come hang at the bar! We’ll have half price wings, apps, and beer all day along with $1 balls 🏈 (Meatballs, Riceballs and Truffle Riceballs)

Rolling with a big group? Book a reservation on OpenTable to secure your spot!

01/29/2026

Send this to someone you want to eat a heart shaped pizza with on Valentine's Day ❤✨

01/26/2026

Do you know how many pounds of actual pasta it took to create our Pretty Penne wall? COMMENT YOUR GUESS BELOW FOR A CHANCE TO WIN A GIFT CARD!
Contest runs until Friday 1/30. Winner will be DM'd and tagged in our story!

01/25/2026
01/25/2026

Planning a celebration? We’ve got the space 🍕🍷
Our semi-private dining area is perfect for gatherings big and small, great food, great drinks, and a space that feels like home.

Address

1789 Richmond Road
Staten Island, NY
10306

If you are using public transport, take the train or bus to Lincoln Avenue station and then walk a few blocks northwards. Alternatively, if you're driving, take Lincoln Avenue and turn at the corner of the gas station. The restaurant is located a few blocks down on the right-hand side. Parking is available along the street as well as in a nearby parking garage.

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 9pm
Tuesday 11am - 9pm
Wednesday 11am - 9pm
Thursday 11am - 9pm
Friday 11am - 10pm
Saturday 11am - 10pm
Sunday 11am - 9pm

Telephone

+12124252623

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Rustic Pizza & Pasteria posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Share

What people say

Italian restaurants are known for their delicious and authentic pizza and pasta dishes, and Rustic Pizza & Pasteria on Lincoln Avenue in New York is no exception. This cozy Italian restaurant offers a wide variety of flavorful and well-crafted pizzas, pastas, and other Italian dishes that are sure to satisfy any craving.

One of the standout features of Rustic Pizza & Pasteria is their customizable pasta menu. With over 8 different pasta options and a variety of sauces to choose from, diners can create their own perfect pasta dish. The Imported Rigatoni with Balsamic Cream Sauce is a must-try for anyone looking for a unique and delicious flavor combination.

In addition to their pasta offerings, Rustic Pizza & Pasteria also serves up some amazing personal pan pies. These individual-sized pizzas are perfect for those who want to try multiple flavors or just enjoy a pizza all to themselves.

For those with a sweet tooth, the house-made Tiramisu is not to be missed. And if you're feeling adventurous, give the Fried Ravioli a try - it's sure to be a hit.

Overall, Rustic Pizza & Pasteria is an excellent choice for anyone looking for authentic Italian cuisine in New York City. With delicious food and friendly service, this restaurant is definitely worth checking out.

Claim ownership or report listing