Recent social media posts
10/23/2026
We’ve disturbed something delicious. 🪦
Chocolate Chunk ice cream, Oreo Cookie Soil, sour gummy worms, whipped cream, and a cookie gravestone. Our Graveyard Dirt Cup Sundae deserves a moment of silence. 🤫 Followed by several bites. 🫦
Come get your hands dirty at select OddFellows scoop shops. Love u.
10/23/2026
CANDY JAR 🫙
Salted sweet cream ice cream with crushed Butterfingers, Nestle Crunch bars, Twix bars and M&Ms. wow all your fave candies from when you went Trick O Treat-ing all in one ice cream scoop. Now at select OddFellows scoop shops. Love u.
10/19/2026
Kids know best! 🤷♀️
Lick the heat Cookies & Cream ice cream you’ll ever have today at all OddFellows Ice Cream scoop shops. Let us know if you agree! 😇🙌🤞
10/09/2026
GRAVEYARD DIRT CUP SUNDAE 🪦
We’ve been digging up some childhood memories. Chocolate ice cream buried in Oreo dirt, sour gummy worms, and whipped cream. Our Graveyard Dirt Cup Sundae is here for spooky season, but we suggest digging in before it’s six feet gone. Love u to death 🖤
Available at select OddFellows scoop shops today🪱
10/07/2026
OddFellows 🤝 Montague Diner. A very serious relationship built on shakes, sundaes, banana splits, and affogatos. Bring a friend. Sharing is between you two.
10/06/2026
Money can’t buy happiness, but it can buy ice cream 🙂↕️
Licks of flavors like Pumpkin Spice Mocha are scooping now at OddFellows Ice Cream Co. in Brooklyn, NYC, NJ, Florida, Pennsylvania and Texas. Love u. 😘
10/05/2026
The leaves are changing, should our soft serve flavors? 🍂🍦🤔
Chocolate and Vanilla soft serve swirling now at OddFellows locations in NYC, New Jersey, and Florida. Add rainbow sprinkles because…of course you should.
What soft serve should we swirl next? 🎤
09/22/2026
Toppings make everything better ✨
Our ice cream can hold its own, but we fully support doing the most. A drizzle of Nutella? Absolutely. Crushed Reese’s Pieces? Pile ’em on. Peep our toppings menu and give your scoop the extras it deserves.
What’s your go to combo? We’re nosy. 👇
09/21/2026
PUMPKIN SPICE MOCHA
Meet Pumpkin Spice Mocha: creamy pumpkin spice ice cream swirled with brown sugar and cinnamon, then finished with chocolate espresso flakes for a rich, crunchy bite. Cozy, spiced, chocolatey, and very much worth bringing up every time someone mentions fall.
Throw on a sweater, grab a spoon, and make this your whole personality for a minute. We support it. Available now at select OddFellows scoop shops. Flavors change often!
09/14/2026
Life is tough. Take a break, grab an ice cream cone and some fresh air. OddFellows is always there for you ❤️
Oh, and drink some water. today
09/04/2026
One thing about me: if you touch my ice cream, we’re about to fight. 😤🍨
09/03/2026
PEACH COBBLER SUNDAE 🍑
September has 30 days. Plan accordingly.
Our limited time Peach Cobbler Sundae comes through with Vanilla Bean ice cream, peach cobbler filling, whipped cream, and cinnamon streusel. Available this month only at select OddFellows scoop shops. Love u🍑
08/31/2026
GOODBYE 👋🍋🍨
Last licks our seasonal LEMON MARSHMALLOW SUNDAE today. Didn’t have a chance to try it? Too bad 🤷♀️
Two scoops of ice cream topped with fresh lemon curd, graham soil, whipped cream and toasted marshmallow fluff plopped on top. WOW if you missed this you should really feel bad.
Don’t worry, new sundae launches tomorrow. Stay tuned!
Address
60 Water St.
New York, NY
11201
60 Water St, New York, NY
Public transport
- Subway: Take the 4 or 5 to Brooklyn Bridge–City Hall (or the A/C to Fulton St). From there, walk toward Water St/Front St in Lower Manhattan.
- Bus: Use MTA routes that stop near Fulton St / Water St (exact line depends on where you’re coming from). Walk the last few blocks along Water St.
Driving + parking
- Drive: Use nearby entrances off I-278 or the FDR Drive depending on your route, then follow signs for Lower Manhattan/Water St.
- Parking: Look for garages along Water St, Front St, and nearby streets (e.g., around Fulton Market area). Street parking is limited—check posted time limits and restrictions before leaving your car.
Alerts
Be the first to know and let us send you an email when OddFellows Ice Cream Co. posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
What people say
OddFellows Ice Cream Co. at 60 Water St. in New York is a standout ice cream parlor known for its small-batch, farm-to-scoop approach and “wildly inventive” flavor creativity. Founded by husband-and-wife team Mohan and Holiday Kumar along with Chef Sam Mason, the business opened its flagship Williamsburg location in June 2013 and has built a reputation for consistently high-quality scoops.
What sets OddFellows apart is how seriously it takes freshness and craft. Every scoop is made from scratch at their farm in Upstate New York, with their ice cream base pasteurized in-house to support rich, distinctive flavors. They source milk, eggs, and cream from local farms and use all-natural ingredients whenever possible—resulting in ice cream that tastes clean, vibrant, and thoughtfully made.
Their super-premium ice cream is produced in small batches, which helps keep the experience exciting while maintaining quality control. Expect inventive takes on classic favorites alongside delectably unconventional creations—each one crafted to highlight real ingredients and careful technique.
If you’re looking for an ice cream shop that blends family-run warmth with chef-level innovation, OddFellows Ice Cream Co. at 60 Water St. is well worth a visit.
