Recent social media posts
06/03/2026
New Flavor Alert!!
Come get a taste of this cream cheese-y goodness. COOKIE BUTTER CHEESECAKE is a cream cheese based ice cream with swirls of biscoff cookie butter and a housemade graham cracker soil mixed throughout.
Chill everyone!! Cookie Butter Cheesecake is scooping at all OddFellows scoop shops in NYC, Florida, Texas and Pennsylvania.
now, being OddFellows and Cookie Butter Cheesecake to a city near you! 💋
06/03/2026
Franchise Today with OddFellows!
Most people see three scoops.
We see dreams coming true.
If you’ve ever dreamed of opening a neighborhood gathering place filled with ice cream, good vibes, and a little bit of oddness, let’s talk.
The world could always use more OddFellows. (And more ice cream.) today
06/01/2026
THIS CHOCOLATE IS HOT 🥵
Sip a cup of Hot Chocolate while you lick a scoop of ice cream at all OddFellows scoop shops today.
Add whipped cream on top, or toasted marshmallow to kick it up a notch.
Fun fact! You can also add peppermint for a Peppermint Hot Chocolate!
FUNNER fact! Add a scoop of ice cream to made it a Choco-gatto ™️
05/31/2026
The choice is easy.
OddFellows Ice Cream Co. is serving creative small-batch ice cream, wild flavor combinations, and the classics done right. Whether you’re an ice cream purist or chasing your next unexpected favorite, there’s always something new to try.
Follow for new flavors, unique sundaes and reach out to franchise today.
05/30/2026
NEW FLAVOR ALERT 🚨
Take a lick out of MISO PEANUT BUTTER & JELLY! A savory miso ice cream with swirls of sour cherry jam and a housemade Nutter Butter Soil.
It’s giving lunch classic with a twist 🙂↕️
miso, peanut butter and jelly is scooping now at all OddFellows Ice Cream shops in Brooklyn, NYC, Pittsburgh, Tampa and the Woodlands. now to bring OddFellows to a town near you today 🥰
05/29/2026
ITS BACK BABYYYYY 💚
Pistachio and Chocolate Soft Serve is swirling softly now at OddFellows Ice Cream in Dumbo and Hyde Park Village. Love u.
05/26/2026
🔥 LAST CALL FOR THE WEIRDEST SUNDAE OF THE SEASON 🔥
The Chorizo Caramel Swirl Sundae is leaving soon which means society is once again rejecting innovation 💁♀️
Don’t miss your last chance to grab this meat and caramel covered ice cream sundae til May 30th.
Exclusive to our Chelsea, Domino Park, Dumbo and Tampa scoop shops. today to bring meat creams to a city near you.
05/23/2026
Would you like this ice cream flavor?
Raspberry ice cream full of toasted almonds, mini marshmallows and dark chocolate chunks. Get that tongue ready for RASPBERRY ROCKY ROAD. Scooping now at all OddFellows shops in Brooklyn, NYC, NJ, Florida, Pennsylvania and Texas. today :)
05/15/2026
New Flavor Alert 🫐
Get that tongue ready for WILD BLUEBERRY! Deep berry flavor. Smooth texture. Tiny bursts of real blueberry tastes throughout.
One of those flavors that somehow tastes nostalgic on the first bite.Wild Blueberry is now scooping at all OddFellows scoop shops today. Love u.
05/14/2026
It’s giving vegan. 🌱
One of our most asked questions is “do you have vegan flavors?” Well boy do we!
Get a lick at our full line-up of vegan scoops. Which flavor’s your first pick?
⚪️ Coconut Mango Sticky Rice
⚪️ Chocolate Chunk
⚪️ Exotic Fruits sorbet
⚪️ Grasshopper
⚪️ Coconut Pandan
New vegan flavor coming this summer!
05/13/2026
A BERRY-TASTIC FLAVOR DROP🫐
Spring just got a whole lot sweeter with these fresh licks. One fan favorite returns, and one brand new scoop enters the villa. Meet RASPBERRY ROCKY ROAD and WILD BLUEBERRY! Now scooping at all OddFellows shops across Brooklyn, NYC, Pittsburgh, Tampa, Wesley Chapel, and the Woodlands. Coming soon to New Jersey!
So… which flavor are you licking first?
05/07/2026
CHOCOLATE TWO WAYS
Are you choosing Chocolate soft serve or Chocolate Chunk hard scooped ice cream? Both available at OddFellows scoop shops today. Love u. 😘
📸 by
05/05/2026
CHORIZO CARAMEL SWIRL SUNDAE
POV: you ordered the oddest thing on the menu… and it’s actually the best thing you’ve ever had 😳🔥
Our limited time Chorizo Caramel Swirl Sundae takes it back all the way to Day 1 of OddFellows, inspired by the odd flavor on our opening day menu. Crispy chorizo paired with sweet salty caramel drizzle mixes perfectly with our oh-so-creamy ice cream.
It’s been around since our early days, and yeah… it’s still that flavor. Be honest, you’re trying this. 🍦✨
The Chorizo Caramel Swirl Sundae is scooping now for a limited time at the Chelsea, Domino Park, Dumbo and Hyde Park Village OddFellows scoop shops today. Love u.
05/04/2026
Hmmmm 👀🤔
Chorizo at the ice cream shop? What seasonal sundae could this be for?
05/03/2026
SALTED CARAMEL TOFFEE
Get that tongue ready for a luscious sweet cream base, swirled with ribbons of golden salted caramel and packed with crunchy, chocolate-dusted toffee pieces. Every scoop is a perfect balance of sweet and salty, creamy and crunchy. Wow, I need a lick now.
Salted Caramel Toffee is scooping now at all OddFellows scoop shops in Brooklyn, NYC, Pittsburgh, Tampa, Wesley Chapel, and Wiregrass. Coming soon to Montclair, NJ and more.
04/20/2026
No better words are spoken.
04/15/2026
Warm Weather = Ice Cream Licks
Vanilla BlackBerry Blondie takes our signature Canilla Bean ice cream and loads it with housemade blondie and vibrant blackberry swirls. WOW 🤩 it’s a party in your mouth, perfect for this warm weather.
Scooping now at OddFellows scoop shops in NYc, Brooklyn, Pittsburgh, Tampa, Wesley Chapel and the Woodlands today
04/12/2026
MATCHA STRAWBERRY ⚡️ COOKIES & CREAM
BROOKLYN BRIDGE PARK ⚡️ PIER 5
Get your licks in at OddFellows Ice Cream shops in Brookl Bridge Park, Chelsea, Domino Park, Dumbo, Hyde Park Village, Wesley Chapel and The Woodlands today.
04/05/2026
HAPPY EASTER 🐣🐇🥚
May y oh r day be filled with Peep themed ice cream concoctions and chocolate…lots of chocolate.
Marshmallow Peep soft serve now in Dumbo and Hyde Park Village.
Peer Massacre Sundaes in Chelsea, Dumbo and Hyde Park Village.
Peep Waffle Cones exclusively in Chelsea
Love u.
04/03/2026
PEEEP THIS SOFT SERVE 🐥🍦
Don’t miss our Marshmallow Peep soft serve! It’s mad cute and tastes even better. Swirling softly now at OddFellows scoop shops in Dumbo and Hyde Park Village for a limited time. Love u.
04/01/2026
NOT AN APRIL FOOLS JOKE 🐥
Marshmallow Peep Soft Serve swirling softly in Dumbo and Hyde Park Village now! We wouldn’t joke about this one.
03/26/2026
LICK ICE CREAM.
OddFellows Ice Cream. Cookies & Cream. Delicious. Now Franchising.
03/24/2026
Everyone’s favorite chocolate ice cream is scooping now! Brooklyn Blackout is a rich, velvety chocolate ice cream swirled with deep layers of moist chocolate cake and is crowned with a decadent, fudgy chocolate fudge ribbon that will have your taste buds doing a happy dance.
Scooping now at all OddFellows scoop shops in NYC, Florida, Pennsylvania, and Texas. Tubs on today :)
Address
60 Water St.
New York, NY
11201
60 Water St, New York, NY
Public transport
- Subway: Take the 4 or 5 to Brooklyn Bridge–City Hall (or the A/C to Fulton St). From there, walk toward Water St/Front St in Lower Manhattan.
- Bus: Use MTA routes that stop near Fulton St / Water St (exact line depends on where you’re coming from). Walk the last few blocks along Water St.
Driving + parking
- Drive: Use nearby entrances off I-278 or the FDR Drive depending on your route, then follow signs for Lower Manhattan/Water St.
- Parking: Look for garages along Water St, Front St, and nearby streets (e.g., around Fulton Market area). Street parking is limited—check posted time limits and restrictions before leaving your car.
Alerts
Be the first to know and let us send you an email when OddFellows Ice Cream Co. posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
What people say
OddFellows Ice Cream Co. at 60 Water St. in New York is a standout ice cream parlor known for its small-batch, farm-to-scoop approach and “wildly inventive” flavor creativity. Founded by husband-and-wife team Mohan and Holiday Kumar along with Chef Sam Mason, the business opened its flagship Williamsburg location in June 2013 and has built a reputation for consistently high-quality scoops.
What sets OddFellows apart is how seriously it takes freshness and craft. Every scoop is made from scratch at their farm in Upstate New York, with their ice cream base pasteurized in-house to support rich, distinctive flavors. They source milk, eggs, and cream from local farms and use all-natural ingredients whenever possible—resulting in ice cream that tastes clean, vibrant, and thoughtfully made.
Their super-premium ice cream is produced in small batches, which helps keep the experience exciting while maintaining quality control. Expect inventive takes on classic favorites alongside delectably unconventional creations—each one crafted to highlight real ingredients and careful technique.
If you’re looking for an ice cream shop that blends family-run warmth with chef-level innovation, OddFellows Ice Cream Co. at 60 Water St. is well worth a visit.
