Sugar Hill Creamery

Sugar Hill Creamery Sugar Hill Creamery is a popular ice cream shop and parlor located on Lexington Avenue. With a commitment to highlighting the stories of Harlemites, this establishment offers a unique and inclusive experience for customers.

Recent social media posts

Meet our new brownie sundae. It’s now in a bowl instead of a cup. It comes with two scoops of your choice of ice cream, ...
10/25/2026

Meet our new brownie sundae. It’s now in a bowl instead of a cup. It comes with two scoops of your choice of ice cream, whipped cream, and your choice of house made caramel or chocolate sauce. Add toppings if you’d like. We’ve got a lot (cake crumble, m&ms, sprinkles, gummy bears, Oreo crumble, candied walnuts/pecans/peanuts). AND, we’re now heating up the brownie!

Enjoy this in-store or for delivery.

10/23/2026

Now serving: Haitian Campfire and The Gasby 🔥🥧

Haitian Campfire is a crème brûlée custard tart in a handmade graham cracker crust, topped with our signature Haitian Hot Chocolate Ice Cream and torched marshmallow fluff.

The Gasby is our housemade peach cobbler with bourbon-roasted peaches and sweet biscuit rounds, served warm with a scoop of cinnamon ice cream.

Perfect for sharing or keeping all to yourself.

📍184 Lenox Avenue
📍3629 Broadway
📍1642 Lexington Avenue

10/23/2026

🥧Thanksgiving Ice Cream Pies are now available for pre-order from all stores! Head to our website to place your order. Pick up begins Friday, November 20th.

🥃Bourbon Pecan Ice Cream Pie
🍠Sweet Potato Ice Cream Pie
🍑 Peach Cobbler Ice Cream Pie

10/22/2026

It Will Always Be Harlem or Nowhere. 💙🧡🍨

🎥 Donjai Gilmore Christina Lane Corinna Vega 🌺

besthotchocolate

10/20/2026

Harlem, let’s get this season started!

We’re screening the season opener tomorrow, Tuesday, October 20, at our Lenox Avenue location! Buy a hot chocolate and get a free sugar cookie shaped like a Knicks jersey or basketball.

Come watch with us! LET’S GO KNICKS 💙🧡

📍 184 Lenox Avenue

10/18/2026

Our hot chocolate bar has entered the chat. Book this cart for your next office party, wedding, or holiday party.

You can also find it in Central Park & 110th St UnityMarketsNY next Saturday!

☕️

10/16/2026

Meet Remember Shorts Weather! 🫐🍓🍋

What started as a fundraiser prize turned into our newest ice cream flavor!

We teamed up with Shakthi Ganesan and Julia Thompson, who won the chance to create their very own Sugar Hill Creamery flavor at a fundraiser benefiting Food & Finance High School and Food Education Fund.

Inspired by their Southern roots and love for Bojangles biscuits, we created a blueberry ice cream with strawberry swirls, lemon curd, and pieces of biscuits mixed right in.

Now scooping at all Sugar Hill Creamery locations.

📍184 Lenox Avenue
📍3629 Broadway
📍1642 Lexington Avenue
📍StuyTown, 21st Street Loop by the fountain (Friday–Sunday until Halloween)

Ice cream + Fall foliage🍁🙂‍↕️🍨What’s your favorite fall treat right now?📸 nowyousee_dr.indy
10/16/2026

Ice cream + Fall foliage🍁🙂‍↕️🍨What’s your favorite fall treat right now?

📸 nowyousee_dr.indy

10/14/2026

Calling all new moms! Find your community at Sugar Hill Creamery🤍

Since 2018, SHMOMS has connected 300+ mothers in Harlem and beyond. Started by our cofounder Petrushka Bazin Larsen, our longest standing community group gives new moms a space to feel seen, heard, and supported.

Our next 6-week group starts this Thursday, October 15, with facilitated conversations about motherhood led by SHMOMS alum Kathleen Coy Chef | Entrepreneur. Come ask questions, share experiences, and build connections that continue through baby supply swaps, late night texts, and midweek walks long after the program ends.

Join through the link in bio, or share this with a new mom who’s looking to build her village.

10/09/2026

24 days. 24 mini cups. 24 sweet surprises. 🎁🍨

Our first-ever Ice Cream Advent Calendar is here! Featuring never-before-seen flavors, returning favorites, and the classics you love. Scratch off each day to reveal what’s inside!

Preorder by November 22nd through the link in our bio to get yours in time for December 1st!

10/06/2026

Our Cinnamon Hot Honey brings together the perfect balance of sweetness, warm cinnamon spice, and a little kick of heat 🔥

Ask for Tell It to the Block at any Sugar Hill Creamery location:

📍184 Lenox Avenue
📍3629 Broadway
📍1642 Lexington Avenue
📍StuyTown, 21st Street Loop by the fountain (Friday–Sunday until Halloween)

Pumpkin bread, hot honey, pear blue cheese. Yes, really.Fall flavors are officially here at Sugar Hill Creamery! We've m...
10/03/2026

Pumpkin bread, hot honey, pear blue cheese. Yes, really.

Fall flavors are officially here at Sugar Hill Creamery! We've made the switch to our seasonal lineup, so stop by for a scoop (or two) while these favorites and new additions are on the menu:

🎃 Walnut Cream Pumpkin Bread Blueberry Apple Swirl
🍎 Apple C***r
🍫 Rocky Road
🧈 Ooey Gooey Butter Cake
🍯 Cinnamon Hot Honey
🍰 Butter Pecan Butter Cake
🌿 Mint Chip
🍐 Pear Blue Cheese

Plus, all your favorite year-round classics.

FIND US TODAY, SATURDAY, OCTOBER 3, AT TWO COMMUNITY EVENTS

🍂 Locke on the Block: Harlem's Community Fall Festival (https://sites.google.com/lockepta.org/lockeontheblock2026/home?authuser=0)
12-4 PM,
W 111th St between 5th Ave & Malcolm X Blvd
Expect bounce houses, crafts, live performances, face painting, STEM activities, delicious food, raffles, and a free kids' clothing swap. Adults are free, and everyone is welcome.

🍂 Jack and Jill Day Community Celebration (https://www.instagram.com/p/Dd86KOeux0i/?hl=en)
12-3 PM
W 120th St between Malcolm X Blvd & Mount Morris Park West
Hosted by the Empire Chapter of Jack and Jill of America with 120 Marcus Meets Malcolm. Enjoy double dutch, robotics and STEM fun, basketball and badminton, four square, musical chairs, face painting, balloon animals, bubbles, a DJ, and book giveaways for kids. Free food, snacks, and drinks while supplies last.

Bring the kids, your neighbors, and the whole crew, and grab a cone while enjoying our beautiful neighborhood and all of the communities that make it great!

VISIT US AT ANY OF OUR LOCATIONS

📍 184 Lenox Avenue
📍 3629 Broadway
📍 1642 Lexington Avenue
📍 StuyTown, 21st Street Loop by the fountain (Friday-Sunday until Halloween)

We can't wait to see you!

Click here for an update from Sugar Hill Creamery!

10/03/2026

Fall flavors are here 🍂🍦

We’ve officially made the switch to our fall lineup. Stop by for a scoop (or two) and enjoy these seasonal favorites while they’re on the menu.

🎃 Walnut Cream Pumpkin Bread
🍎 Apple C***r
🍫 Rocky Road
🧈 Ooey Gooey Butter Cake
🍯 Cinnamon Hot Honey
🍰 Butter Pecan Butter Cake
🌿 Mint Chip
🍐 Pear Blue Cheese

Plus all your favorite year-round classics.

📍184 Lenox Avenue
📍3629 Broadway
📍1642 Lexington Avenue
📍StuyTown, 21st Street Loop by the fountain (Friday–Sunday until Halloween)

10/01/2026

The fastest way to get my attention 🍦🤭

📍184 Lenox Avenue
📍3629 Broadway
📍1642 Lexington Avenue
📍StuyTown, 21st Street Loop by the fountain — Friday–Sunday until Halloween

09/28/2026

You know what time it is 👀

Hot chocolate season is officially here! 🍫☕️

Available now at all locations.

📍184 Lenox Avenue
📍3629 Broadway
📍1642 Lexington Avenue

09/27/2026

It’s a struggle out here…but our hot chocolates are NOW available at all Harlem stores!

📍184 Lenox Avenue, New York, NY 10026
📍3629 Broadway, New York, NY 10031
📍1642 Lexington Avenue, New York, NY 10029

09/26/2026

Due to the storms, there are a few changes to this weekend’s plans:

❌ UnityMarketsNY is canceled and will return on October 3rd.

📅 Yes, Chef Food Fest has been rescheduled for Wednesday, September 30th, from 3–10 PM.

❌ Our StuyTown ice cream truck will be closed Saturday and Sunday.

The good news? Hot chocolate season is coming soon! 🍫

And, we’re open at all three Harlem stores.

Stay safe and dry, everyone!

09/24/2026

Send this to the person you’ve been meaning to meet 🍦💌

📍184 Lenox Avenue
📍3629 Broadway
📍1642 Lexington Avenue
📍StuyTown, 21st Street Loop by the fountain

Last call, young ice cream lovers! 🍦Create your dream flavor for a chance to have it available in our shops and win an i...
09/24/2026

Last call, young ice cream lovers! 🍦

Create your dream flavor for a chance to have it available in our shops and win an ice cream party for your entire class!

Grab an entry form with any purchase at any Sugar Hill Creamery location and submit your flavor by September 27th.

📍184 Lenox Avenue
📍3629 Broadway
📍1642 Lexington Avenue

Address

1642 Lexington Avenue
New York, NY
10029

Public Transport:
- Take the subway to the 125th Street station on the 4, 5, or 6 train lines.
- Walk east on 125th Street towards Lexington Avenue.

Driving/Parking:
- From the north: Take FDR Drive South and exit at 125th Street. Turn left onto Lexington Avenue.
- From the south: Take FDR Drive North and exit at 125th Street. Turn right onto Lexington Avenue.
- There are metered parking spots along Lexington Avenue and nearby streets, as well as parking garages in the area.

Opening Hours

Monday 2pm - 10pm
Tuesday 2pm - 10pm
Wednesday 2pm - 10pm
Thursday 2pm - 10pm
Friday 2pm - 10pm
Saturday 2pm - 10pm
Sunday 2pm - 10pm

Telephone

+12126349004

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Sugar Hill Creamery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category

Chain

What people say

Sugar Hill Creamery on Lexington Avenue is a delightful ice cream shop that captures the essence of community and authenticity. The warm and welcoming atmosphere invites you to indulge in their delectable treats while feeling right at home.

Their rainbow cookie sandwich, paired with a scoop of A$AP ROCK ROAD ice cream, is a must-try combination that will surely satisfy your sweet cravings. The vibrant colors and flavors come together harmoniously to create a truly delightful experience for your taste buds.

What sets Sugar Hill Creamery apart is not just their delicious offerings, but also their commitment to supporting and celebrating the local community. Through their featured stories of Harlemites like Denya, they showcase the diverse voices and experiences that make Harlem such a special place. It's heartwarming to see a business that values inclusivity and connection with its surroundings.

With plans to stay rooted in Harlem for the long run, Sugar Hill Creamery embodies a sense of belonging and dedication to their neighborhood. Whether you're stopping by for a quick treat or looking to immerse yourself in the rich culture of Harlem, this charming ice cream parlor is sure to leave you with a smile on your face and a satisfied palate.