Sammy's Fish Box

Sammy's Fish Box Sammy's Fish Box is a family style seafood restaurant that has been serving quality, fresh and affordable meals since 1966. Located in City Island, it has grown from a 26-seat snack bar to a 500-seat restaurant with patrons coming from Manhattan, Queens, Brooklyn and Connecticut all year round. The restaurant serves the very best quality food prepared fresh daily by uncompromising chefs and served at reasonable prices in generous portions. Sammy's Fish Box thanks its loyal customers for their support and invites them to try out their sister restaurants: Sammy's Shrimp Box, Sea Shore Restaurant, Seaside Johnnies, Pier Restaurant & Tiki Bar.
(11271)

Recent social media posts

10/22/2026

The Beef Dinosaur Rib at Sammys Smoke House

Everything it’s supposed to be 😋

Fish Kabob 🐟
10/21/2026

Fish Kabob 🐟

10/19/2026
Sammy’s all weekend 🍤
10/16/2026

Sammy’s all weekend 🍤

10/14/2026

🔥 BIG BBQ flavor right here in the Bronx!

Come hungry and see what’s cooking at Sammy’s Smokehouse! 🍖🔥

📍 64 City Island Avenue, directly across the street from Sammy’s Fish Box!

Seafood is always a good idea
10/12/2026

Seafood is always a good idea

10/09/2026

A juicy ribeye steak paired with golden fried shrimp — one combo that knows how to do a little bit of everything. 🥩🍤

You’ll find this one at Sammy’s Smokehouse, right across the street from Sammy’s Fish Box!

Same family, another reason to love City Island. ❤️

10/06/2026

Right across from Sammy’s Fish Box, you’ll find Sammy’s Smokehouse — same family, a whole different experience. 🍖🔥

BBQ, seafood, big plates, cold drinks… this is how we do it on City Island. 🎶😎

📍 Sammy’s Smokehouse — directly across the street from Sammy’s Fish Box.

09/30/2026

Seafood + BBQ Combo available at the smokehouse!

Lobster + Shrimp Combo 🦞🍤
09/30/2026

Lobster + Shrimp Combo 🦞🍤

09/25/2026

We may be at the smokehouse, but don’t forget about the seafood. 🦞👀

Whole steam Maine lobster and golden fried shrimp 🍤

09/15/2026

The best of both worlds 🔥🦀 Our juicy, tender brisket paired with two clusters of snow crab, crispy onion rings, and golden melted butter. This is the Brisket & Snow Combo at Sammy’s smokehouse! 🤤

Address

41 City Island Avenue
The Bronx, NY
10464

To reach City Island Avenue in The Bronx, you can take the 6 train to Pelham Bay Park station and then transfer to the BX29 bus towards City Island. Alternatively, you can drive and park in one of the public parking lots near the street or find street parking if available.

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 1am
Tuesday 11am - 1am
Wednesday 11am - 1am
Thursday 11am - 1am
Friday 11am - 1am
Saturday 11am - 1am
Sunday 11am - 1am

Telephone

+17188850920

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Sammy's Fish Box posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Share

What people say

Seafood restaurants are known for their fresh and delicious seafood dishes that leave customers craving for more. Sammy's Fish Box, located on City Island Avenue in New York, is one such restaurant that has been serving quality seafood since 1966. What started as a small snack bar with just 26 seats has now grown into a full-service restaurant with over 500 seats, serving over a million meals annually.

Sammy's Fish Box believes in the traditional formula of serving the best quality food prepared fresh daily at affordable prices. Their commitment to quality and value has earned them respect and loyalty from their customers over the years. The portions served at Sammy's Fish Box are generous, ensuring that customers leave satisfied and happy.

Apart from their delicious seafood dishes, Sammy's Fish Box also offers excellent service to its customers. The staff is friendly and attentive, making sure that every customer feels welcome and comfortable.

If you're looking for a seafood restaurant that serves fresh and delicious seafood dishes at affordable prices, then Sammy's Fish Box is the place to be. Whether you're a local or a tourist visiting New York City, make sure to visit this restaurant on City Island Avenue for an unforgettable dining experience.