Recent social media posts
06/03/2026
Bring your lawn chair β tonight weβre screening the Knicks game outside Sugar Hill Creamery on Lenox Ave. π΅π
Come watch Game 1 with us and grab a scoop of our brand new flavor: Go New York, Go New York, Go β birthday cake, blue and orange, and gluten-free.
π 184 Lenox Ave
ποΈ Tonight Β· While supplies last
06/03/2026
Can you guess the flavor? πDrop your guesses below β itβll be available at our stores on Lenox Ave and Broadway tomorrow. Come find out if youβre right.
ALSO, weβll be screening the game at the Lenox Ave. store.
π184 Lenox Avenue, New York, NY 10026
π3629 Broadway, New York, NY 10031
06/02/2026
The #1 sign something is seriously wrong.
π184 Lenox Avenue, New York, NY 10026
π3629 Broadway, New York, NY 10031
π1642 Lexington Avenue, New York, NY 10029
πStuyTown, 21st Street Loop by the fountain, New York, NY 10029 (May-Sept, Scoops Only)
06/01/2026
This is what after work looks like on Lenox Avenue β a scoop with a friend, the best kind of happy hour. π¦ Tag the person you need to catch up with. π―
Get ice cream with a friend:
π184 Lenox Avenue, New York, NY 10026
π3629 Broadway, New York, NY 10031
π1642 Lexington Avenue, New York, NY 10029
πStuyTown, 21st Street Loop by the fountain, New York, NY 10029 (May-Sept)
π
πΈ
06/01/2026
A tricycle. A community garden. A wedding. π€
During COVID, the bride walked to our Lenox Avenue store for a cup of blueberry cheesecake ice cream during one of the hardest seasons many of us have ever lived through. This weekend, she and her partner included us in their celebration of love.
We scooped through cocktail hour, which they called an ice cream social, and watched a community of people celebrate two people who chose each other β and chose us to be part of it.
This is one of the reasons we do what we do.
Planning a wedding?
Weβd love to be part of your day. π¦
05/30/2026
Everything about this picture of at our store on Lenox Ave makes us happy β from the fact that one of our neighbors took it (with permission) and sent it to us, to the fact that we were on Sheryl Lee Ralphβs radar. It speaks to the dreams we held when we opened almost nine years ago: to be a place for neighbors and a destination for visitors coming to Harlem. Our heart is full.
05/29/2026
NOW SCOOPING Nunuβs Peach Cobbler π
Pureed ripe peaches, a dash of cinnamon, and homemade crisp come together in a scoop that tastes like summer.
Send this to a peach cobbler lover.
π184 Lenox Avenue, New York, NY 10026
π3629 Broadway, New York, NY 10031
π1642 Lexington Avenue, New York, NY 10029
πStuyTown, 21st Street Loop by the fountain, New York, NY 10029 (MayβSept, Scoops Only)
05/28/2026
Blueberry cheesecake and ice cream had a baby. Weβre calling her Harlem-Style Cheesecake. π°π«
Available at all of our Harlem stores and on (web pre-order recommended).
π184 Lenox Avenue, New York, NY 10026
π3629 Broadway, New York, NY 10031
π1642 Lexington Avenue, New York, NY 10029
05/28/2026
Just following doctorβs orders π¨
If evening walks always ended like this, weβd never miss one.
π184 Lenox Avenue, New York, NY 10026
π3629 Broadway, New York, NY 10031
π1642 Lexington Avenue, New York, NY 10029
πStuyTown, 21st Street Loop by the fountain, New York, NY 10029 (May - Sept, Scoops Only)
05/27/2026
Turn your obstacles into popsicles. Happy Wednesday!
π184 Lenox Avenue, New York, NY 10026
π3629 Broadway, New York, NY 10031
π1642 Lexington Avenue, New York, NY 10029
πStuyTown, 21st Street Loop by the fountain, New York, NY 10029
05/26/2026
Our Vanilla Ice Cream + Jarritos Mandarin Soda = How Harlem Does Ice Cream
Available in-store and for delivery
π 184 Lenox Ave (Central Harlem)
π 3629 Broadway (Hamilton Heights)
π 1642 Lexington Ave (East Harlem)
π Stuytown β 21st Street Fountain (seasonal) Only scoops available
05/25/2026
Weβre open at all four locations and if youβre on our mailing or text message list, check your messages for a special offer. It can only be redeemed today if youβre on the list. οΏΌ
OUR LOCATIONS:
π 184 Lenox Ave (Central Harlem)
π 3629 Broadway (Hamilton Heights)
π 1642 Lexington Ave (East Harlem)
π Stuytown β 21st Street Fountain (seasonal)
05/25/2026
Buy 2 pints, get a free scoop β today only!
It's a grey one out there today β but that's exactly what ice cream is for.
We're open at all three Harlem locations and in StuyTown, and to make your Memorial Day Monday a little sweeter, we're running a special today only:
Buy any two pints and get a free single scoop in a cup on us. Any flavor in the case. In-store, in Harlem only.
One thing to note β this offer is valid on pre-packed pints only. Hand-packed pints are not included.
No catch... well, there is one. You must show this email to redeem!
TRY SOME OF OUR FAVORITES:
π« Blueberry Cheesecake
π Banana Pudding -- leaving soon
π« Dark Chocolate (vegan)
π― Honey Lavender -- leaving soon
π Soursop (vegan) -- leaving soon
π Orange Blossom Special -- leaving soon
β CafΓ© Touba -- leaving soon
And more...
WE'RE OPEN AT ALL LOCATIONS:
π 184 Lenox Ave (Central Harlem)
π 3629 Broadway (Hamilton Heights)
π 1642 Lexington Ave (East Harlem)
π Stuytown β 21st Street Fountain (seasonal)
See you today!
Click here for an update from Sugar Hill Creamery!
05/24/2026
Milkshakes just got an upgrade. Any of our 12 handmade flavors β blended, malted, whipped cream on top. Blueberry cheesecake shake? Cookies and caramel shake? Yup.
π 184 Lenox Avenue, New York, NY 10026
π 3629 Broadway, New York, NY 10031
π 1642 Lexington Avenue, New York, NY 10029
05/23/2026
Some needs are non-negotiable. A brownie sundae is one of them π« π¨
05/21/2026
NYC banana pudding fansβ¦ youβve been doing it wrong. π
Okay, not wrong β but you havenβt had it like this.
We donβt just toss banana and cookies into ice cream and call it a day. We take ripe banana, velvety pudding-style cream, and Nilla wafers, layer them all together, then dice it up and fold those chunks back into every bucket. π¦
Translation: actual banana pudding, in scoopable form, made by hand in Harlem.
Come taste the version that ruins all other versions for you. π
π 184 Lenox Avenue, New York, NY 10026
π 3629 Broadway, New York, NY 10031
π 1642 Lexington Avenue, New York, NY 10029
05/15/2026
Hello, weekend.
Ice cream sundae with house made chocolate sauce and caramel sauce, brownies, milk chocolate ice cream with salted pecan blondie, and fresh whipped cream
Build your own with your choice of two ice cream flavors, toppings, and sauces.
Available in-store and for delivery
05/15/2026
The Peopleβs Money is here π΅π₯
A swirl of matcha ice cream, mango, and chewy mochi made in collaboration with NYC CEC.
Stop by any Sugar Hill Creamery location for a scoop or pint - and cast your ballot in-store before voting closes June 21 π¦
05/10/2026
Happy Motherβs Day π NEW Matcha Mango Mochi just dropped β creamy matcha, sweet mango swirls, chewy mochi pieces. Spring in a scoop. π΅π₯
π LAST CHANCE: Our Motherβs Day giveaway closes TONIGHT at midnight. Tag a mom who deserves a treat on our giveaway post to enter. Winners announced Monday!
Weβre open at all 4 locations today. Bring Mom through. π¦
πΈ .wrote.it
05/10/2026
All 4 locations open β plus last chance to enter our giveaway!
Happy Mother's Day! π
Whether she's your mom, your grandmother, your chosen family, or you're treating yourself β today's the day to make it sweet.
π΅ NEW: MATCHA MANGO MOCHI
Our newest flavor just dropped and it's giving spring. Creamy matcha ice cream with sweet mango swirls and chewy mochi pieces throughout.
Our giveaway closes TONIGHT at midnight!
Head to our Instagram, tag a mom who deserves a treat, and you could win:
π₯ Grand Prize: $100 Sugar Hill Creamery gift card
π¦ 7 Runners-Up: $25 gift cards each
Every comment = one entry. Tag as many moms as you want. Winners announced Monday in our Stories.
π Enter now: (https://www.instagram.com/p/DYFNHREx4XW/)
PLUS ALL YOUR FAVORITES:
π« Blueberry Cheesecake
π Banana Pudding
π― Honey Lavender
π Orange Blossom Special
β CafΓ© Touba
And more...
WE'RE OPEN AT ALL LOCATIONS:
π 184 Lenox Ave (Central Harlem)
π 3629 Broadway (Hamilton Heights)
π 1642 Lexington Ave (East Harlem)
π Stuytown β 21st Street Fountain (seasonal)
Bring Mom. Bring the kids. Bring the whole crew.
See you today!
Click here for an update from Sugar Hill Creamery!
05/08/2026
Weβre giving away ice cream for Motherβs Day!π¦
Drop a comment and tag a mom who:
β
deserves a treat
β
does the most
β
raised you, as a mother or like a mother
Every comment is one entry. Tag as many people as you like, one tag per comment.
THE PRIZES
π₯ 1 grand prize β $100 gift card
π¦ 7 prizes β $25 gift card each
Redeemable in-store at any of our three Harlem locations or in .
THE DETAILS
β° Closes Sunday, May 10 at midnight
π 8 winners chosen at random
π’ Winners announced Monday, May 12 in our Stories
β³ Winners have 48 hours to claim via DM
πTo every mom, every mom-to-be, and those who are mothering in ways seen and unseen β weβre sending so much love this weekend. You deserve rest, celebration, and ice cream.
Happy Motherβs Day from our family to yours. π©΅
π184 Lenox Avenue, New York, NY 10026
π3629 Broadway, New York, NY 10031
π1642 Lexington Avenue, New York, NY 10029
πStuyTown, 21st Street Loop by the fountain, New York, NY 10029
besticecream
05/08/2026
Now scooping The Peopleβs Money β matcha, mango, mochi, and democracy. π¦π€
Available at all three Harlem locations.
Grab a scoop or a pint β and cast your ballot in-store before voting closes June 21st. π³οΈ
05/05/2026
Third season in StuyTown. Find us by the fountainπ¦
05/05/2026
May the 4th, but make it fancy β¨ Meet Erro-O-Wan β our Fennel Creamsicle with creamy orange, fennel seed, and a subtle licorice twist.
π184 Lenox Avenue, New York, NY 10026
π3629 Broadway, New York, NY 10031
π1642 Lexington Avenue, New York, NY 10029
04/28/2026
Now scooping banana pudding ice cream! πTag someone who needs to know about this.
π184 Lenox Avenue, New York, NY 10026
π3629 Broadway, New York, NY 10031
π1642 Lexington Avenue, New York, NY 10029
Address
55 Water Street
New York, NY
11201
To reach Water Street in New York via public transport, you can take the subway to the Fulton Street station. From there, walk east on Fulton Street and turn left onto Water Street.
If you prefer to drive, take the FDR Drive and exit at South Street. Continue on South Street until you reach Water Street.
Parking options in the area include street parking (metered) or nearby parking garages such as the one located on Pearl Street.
Alerts
Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Sugar Hill Creamery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
What people say
Sugar Hill Creamery on Water Street in New York is a delightful ice cream shop that has captured the hearts of locals and visitors alike. Their creative flavors and welcoming atmosphere make it a must-visit destination for anyone with a sweet tooth.
One of the highlights at Sugar Hill Creamery is their rainbow cookies, which are a fan favorite. Customers are urged to grab them while they're still available, as they tend to sell out quickly. Pairing these colorful treats with a scoop of their signature A$AP ROCK ROAD ice cream creates a mouthwatering combination that is sure to satisfy any craving.
Beyond their delicious treats, Sugar Hill Creamery also shines a spotlight on the vibrant community of Harlem. Through featured stories like Denya's, customers get a glimpse into the diverse and supportive environment that makes this neighborhood so special. Denya's heartfelt words about feeling supported, loved, and safe in Harlem truly encapsulate the sense of belonging that Sugar Hill Creamery fosters.
With plans to stay rooted in Harlem for the long run and an upcoming archive of featured Harlemites on their website, Sugar Hill Creamery is not just an ice cream shop - it's a hub of connection and celebration of community spirit.
For those looking for more than just a sweet treat, Sugar Hill Creamery offers an experience that nourishes both the body and soul. Visit them on Water Street to indulge in delicious ice cream while immersing yourself in the warmth and authenticity of Harlem's vibrant culture.
