Recent social media posts
09/07/2026
We’re open today in Harlem + StuyTown for regular business hours. Come by for a scoop!
📍184 Lenox Avenue - 2–11pm
📍3629 Broadway - 2–11pm
📍1642 Lexington Avenue - 3–10pm
📍StuyTown, 21st Street Loop by the fountain - 3–9pm
09/05/2026
We’re staying up late tonight 🍦🪩
Come say goodbye to summer and kick off West Indian Day Parade weekend with us at Lenox Ave from 10:30 PM–1 AM.
Scoops, canned nutcrackers from drinkbeloved, and music by katastrophe all night long.
📍184 Lenox Avenue
⏰ 10:30 PM–1 AM
09/04/2026
📣 S A V E · T H E S E · D A T E S
🍦 END OF SUMMER ICE CREAM PARTY (Saturday, Sept 5, until 1am at Lenox) — We’re sending summer off with late-night scoops, music by DJ KATATSTROPHIK, and canned nutcrackers by Beloved. Party will be at 184 Lenox Ave.
🎒 BACK TO SCHOOL FLAVOR COMPETITION (Sept 8–27) — Calling all young ice cream lovers! Create your very own ice cream flavor for a chance to win an ice cream party for your entire class.
🍗 YES, CHEF FOOD FEST (Sept 26–27, 11am–7pm at Citi Field) — Chicken & Ice cream is back! Find us at Yes, Chef Food Fest with Charles Pan-Fried Chicken for another round of the combo you know and love.
🍨 NYC W**E & FOOD FESTIVAL (Oct 18 at The Seaport) — We’re headed to NYCWFF and bringing our Bevy Smith collab with us. Come find us for a scoop of Miss Lolly’s Butter Pecan & Butter Cake
09/04/2026
🙂↕️ Tag the person you’re getting your last summer scoops with but also, we’ll be here in the fall, too. K? 🤗
📍184 Lenox Avenue, New York, NY 10026
📍3629 Broadway, New York, NY 10031
📍1642 Lexington Avenue, New York, NY 10029
📍StuyTown, 21st Street Loop by the fountain, New York, NY 10029
09/01/2026
Join us for an end-of-summer late-night ice cream party in Harlem as we pregame the Caribbean Day Parade! 🍦🎶
We’ll have music by katastrophe, canned nutcrackers from drinkbeloved, and plenty of scoops to keep the long weekend going.
Come grab a scoop, a drink, and celebrate the end of summer with us.
🗓️ Saturday, September 5
⏰ Open late until 1 AM
📍184 Lenox Avenue, New York, NY 10026
09/01/2026
One of the few weekly routines we can get behind 🙈
Come get your scoop:
📍184 Lenox Avenue, New York, NY 10026
📍3629 Broadway, New York, NY 10031
📍1642 Lexington Avenue, New York, NY 10029
📍StuyTown, 21st Street Loop by the fountain, New York, NY 10029
08/29/2026
It’s Michael Jackson’s birthday today and we’re celebrating with free scoops of a flavor we made in collaboration with MJ.
The first 50 guests at our Lenox store will enjoy a free scoop in a cup of “Mic Drop,” dark chocolate and vanilla ice cream with black and white cookies folded within.
We’re also scooping:
“Keep it Awthentic” made in collaboration with musical artists JSWISS
“Lolly’s Butter Cake” made in collaboration with bevy smith and Stephanie Smith Long
Celebrate the end of summer with ice cream inspired by our arts and culture icons.
📍 184 Lenox Avenue, New York, NY 10026 (free scoops only available here)
📍 3629 Broadway, New York, NY 10031
📍 1642 Lexington Avenue, New York, NY 10029
📍 StuyTown, 21st Street Loop by the fountain, New York, NY 10029 (May–Sept, scoops only)
📍Unity Farmer’s Market, Lenox Ave & W. 110th St in Central Park (Saturdays only)
08/27/2026
How do you celebrate Michael Jackson’s birthday in Harlem? With a special scoop, of course 🎤🍦
We teamed up with MJ to create a flavor inspired by “Black or White” and the iconic New York City black-and-white cookie, featuring dark chocolate and vanilla ice cream with pieces of black-and-white cookies folded throughout.
Join us at our Lenox Avenue shop on Saturday, August 29! The first 50 guests will receive a complimentary scoop 🖤🤍
📍184 Lenox Ave, Harlem
08/25/2026
Build your own ice cream sandwich with any flavor of ice cream.🤤🍪🍦
Choose any flavor and have it sandwiched between two soft, chewy chocolate chip cookies.
Available at any Sugar Hill Creamery!
📍 184 Lenox Avenue, New York, NY 10026
📍 3629 Broadway, New York, NY 10031
📍 1642 Lexington Avenue, New York, NY 10029
08/24/2026
We are so excited to introduce our next Harlemite, bevy smith, Harlem native, author, actress, radio and television personality, and host of In Bed with Bevy!
We ran into Bevy in the neighborhood while she was on her way to pick up supplies for her sister Stephanie’s business, Stephanie Smith Long, and naturally, we had to invite her over to make an ice cream flavor with us!
Miss Lolly was Bevy and Stephanie’s mother and the inspiration behind Miss Lolly’s Kitchen. Every Sunday, she would make a huge family meal complete with two meats, plenty of sides, and her homemade cakes and pies. One of Bevy’s favorites was her butter cake, served just the way Miss Lolly loved it, with a dollop of butter pecan ice cream on top. 🍰🍦
So we brought the two together and created Miss Lolly’s Butter Cake, our take on a family tradition and a sweet memory of Miss Lolly.
A portion of the sales from Miss Lolly’s Butter Cake will go back to The Brotherhood Sister Sol, an organization doing incredible work with young people right here in Harlem.
Thank you, Bevy, for sharing Miss Lolly’s story and this special family memory with us ❤️ And thank you to The Best Of Harlem for documenting the conversation!
Miss Lolly’s Butter Cake is available at all Harlem stores.
08/20/2026
Is it just us? 🤷🏽♀️
Now scooping: Opal Lee (Burnt Sugar Cake)
📍 184 Lenox Avenue, New York, NY 10026
📍 3629 Broadway, New York, NY 10031
📍 1642 Lexington Avenue, New York, NY 10029
📍 StuyTown, 21st Street Loop by the fountain, New York, NY 10029 (May–Sept, scoops only)
08/19/2026
Would you have waited in this line for chicken + ice cream? 🍗🍦
Harlem showed OUT for the last Sunday of our collab with Harlem's Finest Soul-Food
The line wrapped around the block, the energy never let up, and Sunday’s Sundae was worth the wait.
Thank you to everyone who came out and made this collaboration one we won’t forget.
Until we meet again, chicken + ice cream 🖤🍨🍗
08/16/2026
Experience Harlem Food History — We’ll be on 145th St AND 72nd St from 1-5pm today - Sunday, August 16th.
Chicken and Ice Cream Sundae 🍨🍗
08/15/2026
One more Sunday. One more chance for chicken + ice cream. 🍗🍦
We’re running it back with Harlem's Finest Soul-Food one last time (for now!) and this time, Sunday’s Sundae is available at TWO Charles Pan-Fried Chicken locations.
📍 146 W 72nd St.
📍 340 W 145th St.
🗓 Sunday, August 16
⏰ 1–5 PM, rain or shine
Plus, our friends at Beloved will be handing out free drinks to anyone 21+ in line, while supplies last.
Don’t miss your chance to try it before it’s gone.
Address
55 Water Street
New York, NY
11201
To reach Water Street in New York via public transport, you can take the subway to the Fulton Street station. From there, walk east on Fulton Street and turn left onto Water Street.
If you prefer to drive, take the FDR Drive and exit at South Street. Continue on South Street until you reach Water Street.
Parking options in the area include street parking (metered) or nearby parking garages such as the one located on Pearl Street.
Alerts
Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Sugar Hill Creamery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
What people say
Sugar Hill Creamery on Water Street in New York is a delightful ice cream shop that has captured the hearts of locals and visitors alike. Their creative flavors and welcoming atmosphere make it a must-visit destination for anyone with a sweet tooth.
One of the highlights at Sugar Hill Creamery is their rainbow cookies, which are a fan favorite. Customers are urged to grab them while they're still available, as they tend to sell out quickly. Pairing these colorful treats with a scoop of their signature A$AP ROCK ROAD ice cream creates a mouthwatering combination that is sure to satisfy any craving.
Beyond their delicious treats, Sugar Hill Creamery also shines a spotlight on the vibrant community of Harlem. Through featured stories like Denya's, customers get a glimpse into the diverse and supportive environment that makes this neighborhood so special. Denya's heartfelt words about feeling supported, loved, and safe in Harlem truly encapsulate the sense of belonging that Sugar Hill Creamery fosters.
With plans to stay rooted in Harlem for the long run and an upcoming archive of featured Harlemites on their website, Sugar Hill Creamery is not just an ice cream shop - it's a hub of connection and celebration of community spirit.
For those looking for more than just a sweet treat, Sugar Hill Creamery offers an experience that nourishes both the body and soul. Visit them on Water Street to indulge in delicious ice cream while immersing yourself in the warmth and authenticity of Harlem's vibrant culture.
