Clicky

Prodigy Coffee

Prodigy Coffee Prodigy Coffee was a cozy coffee shop located on Carmine Street in the West Village of New York. They prided themselves on serving their local community the finest global coffee alongside warm and welcoming service every day of the year. Prodigy Coffee roasted their small batch coffees in Brooklyn, NY and offered a selection of pastries from some of the most renowned bakers in NYC. The creative hub also served as a place for neighborhood regulars to produce screenplays, books, poems and personal musings while enjoying their fresh coffee and delicious baked goods. Unfortunately, this restaurant has permanently closed.

Recent social media posts

Dear Friends!  As the year is nearing its end, so is our time at 33 Carmine Street!  It has been 10 years since Prodigy ...
11/30/2022

Dear Friends! 
 
As the year is nearing its end, so is our time at 33 Carmine Street! 
 
It has been 10 years since Prodigy Coffee first opened its doors. Mainly to brew and serve coffee, yet little did we expect all the amazing friendships and connections we have been so lucky to also brew during our time here. Thank you so much for making a difference to us.  
  
Any sad face would make the day difficult for us, so let’s focus on all the positive things, continue smiling, throw a few jokes in there and let us brew you off to another good day :)
 
Love 
Team Prodigy

Happy Thanksgiving 🍁Thursday 11/24 closedFriday 11/25 8:30am-4pmSaturday 11/26 8:30am-4pmSunday 11/27 8:30-4pm
11/23/2022

Happy Thanksgiving 🍁
Thursday 11/24 closed
Friday 11/25 8:30am-4pm
Saturday 11/26 8:30am-4pm
Sunday 11/27 8:30-4pm

We will be closed.Labor Day!See you Tuesday ☕️
09/05/2022

We will be closed.Labor Day!
See you Tuesday ☕️

July 4th weekend opening hours:Saturday 7/2 coffee 8:30-4wine 5-10Sunday 7/3coffee 8:30-4Monday 7/4closed
07/02/2022

July 4th weekend opening hours:
Saturday 7/2
coffee 8:30-4
wine 5-10
Sunday 7/3
coffee 8:30-4
Monday 7/4
closed

HAPPY 2022!Thank you for all your support during the past year 💕See you Monday 1/3 @7:30am!
01/01/2022

HAPPY 2022!
Thank you for all your support during the past year 💕
See you Monday 1/3 @7:30am!

Thankful for all of you - we will be pouring coffee tomorrow (11/25) from 8am - 12pm ☕️
11/24/2021

Thankful for all of you - we will be pouring coffee tomorrow (11/25) from 8am - 12pm ☕️

Happy Labor Day weekend! We will be closed Monday 9/6 and open again Tuesday 7:30am-3:30pm.
09/05/2021

Happy Labor Day weekend! We will be closed Monday 9/6 and open again Tuesday 7:30am-3:30pm.

Due to the storm, we will be closed today. See you all tomorrow for your morning coffee ☀️
08/22/2021

Due to the storm, we will be closed today. See you all tomorrow for your morning coffee ☀️

Cool off with an iced cortado in the morning and a glass of natural wine in the evening! Wine and tapas open from 5:30 🌙
07/15/2021

Cool off with an iced cortado in the morning and a glass of natural wine in the evening! Wine and tapas open from 5:30 🌙

Surprise! Now also serving natural wine and tapas 5:30 - 10 🍷
06/19/2021

Surprise! Now also serving natural wine and tapas 5:30 - 10 🍷

Cool off with a blood orange iced tea in our new structure! 🍊
06/16/2021

Cool off with a blood orange iced tea in our new structure! 🍊

Summer is here ☀️ Open Mon - Fri 7:30 - 3:30 and Sat - Sun 8:30 - 3:30
05/18/2021

Summer is here ☀️ Open Mon - Fri 7:30 - 3:30 and Sat - Sun 8:30 - 3:30

Address

33 Carmine Street
New York, NY
10014

To reach Carmine Street in New York, you can take the subway (train line 1) and get off at the Christopher Street-Sheridan Square station. From there, walk south on 7th Avenue until you reach Carmine Street.

If driving, you can park on the street or in a nearby parking garage such as Garage Management Company located on 66 Leroy St.

Please note that these directions are not specific to any particular establishment.

Opening Hours

Monday 8am - 3pm
Tuesday 8am - 3pm
Wednesday 8am - 3pm
Thursday 8am - 3pm
Friday 8am - 3pm
Saturday 9am - 3pm
Sunday 9am - 3pm

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Prodigy Coffee posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Share

Category

What people say

Prodigy Coffee is a must-visit coffee shop in the West Village of New York. This little gem offers an exceptional coffee experience, with freshly roasted small batch coffees from Brooklyn and world-class espresso. The warm and welcoming service adds to the charm of this intimate space on Carmine Street.

In addition to their outstanding coffee, Prodigy Coffee also offers a selection of delicious baked goods from renowned bakers in NYC. The combination of great coffee and tasty treats makes for the perfect pick-me-up any time of day.

What sets Prodigy Coffee apart is its creative atmosphere, where neighborhood regulars come together to produce screenplays, books, poems, and personal musings. It's a hub of culture and flavor that you won't find anywhere else.

Overall, Prodigy Coffee is a fantastic spot for anyone looking for a top-notch coffee experience in New York City. With friendly service and a cozy atmosphere, it's no wonder why this place has become a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

Claim ownership or report listing