Clicky

Brooklyn's Finest Pizza & Restaurant

Brooklyn's Finest Pizza & Restaurant Brooklyn's Finest Pizza & Restaurant is a pizza place located on Hylan Boulevard, offering a selection of local Brooklyn favorites including panelles and egg creams. The restaurant was founded by Joseph Compitello who was born and raised in the Park Slope section of Brooklyn and gained an appreciation for good food from eating at local restaurants. Enjoy a taste of Brooklyn in Staten Island with their unique home style dishes.

Recent social media posts

NBA FINALS BEGIN WEDNESDAY!!! We got the perfect space for your KNICKS WATCH PARTY. 75” tv, private room!!! 718-815-7070...
05/30/2026

NBA FINALS BEGIN WEDNESDAY!!! We got the perfect space for your KNICKS WATCH PARTY. 75” tv, private room!!! 718-815-7070 or text 347-216-9053

Watch the Knicks with your group in our PRIVATE PARTY ROOM. Rent the room, BYOB , enjoy the finals with your crew. Food ...
05/26/2026

Watch the Knicks with your group in our PRIVATE PARTY ROOM. Rent the room, BYOB , enjoy the finals with your crew. Food can be added on. 718-815-7070 or text 347-216-9053. Ask for Rob

Don’t let the rain ruin your Memorial Day plans. WE GOT TOU COVERED!!! We’re cooking up specials all weekend long and WE...
05/21/2026

Don’t let the rain ruin your Memorial Day plans. WE GOT TOU COVERED!!! We’re cooking up specials all weekend long and WE ARE OPEN ON MEMORIAL DAY. LET US COOK FOR YOU!!! Most ordered can be placed same day, catering hero’s one day in advance. 718-815-7070

Going out to eat isn’t for everyone. Sometimes you just wanna stay in and celebrate. THATS WHERE WE COME IN. THIS MOTHER...
05/06/2026

Going out to eat isn’t for everyone. Sometimes you just wanna stay in and celebrate. THATS WHERE WE COME IN. THIS MOTHERS DAY LET US DO THE COOKING!!! any size gathering, we got you covered. Free delivery available. 718-815-7070

05/01/2026
In the steam table today we are featuring TUSCAN CHICKEN. Chicken Cutlets topped w/ Creamy Spinach & Artichoke finished ...
05/01/2026

In the steam table today we are featuring TUSCAN CHICKEN. Chicken Cutlets topped w/ Creamy Spinach & Artichoke finished with Sundried Tomatoes. Served w/ mashed potatoes. $12
Get it while you can!!! 718-815-7070

Meatloaf and Mashed. Come and get it. For $10 ya can’t beat it. 718-815-7070
04/30/2026

Meatloaf and Mashed. Come and get it. For $10 ya can’t beat it. 718-815-7070

On the counter today we feature our “Not Quite Birria”. Birria style steak tips w/ Spanish rice. This one hits with ever...
04/21/2026

On the counter today we feature our “Not Quite Birria”. Birria style steak tips w/ Spanish rice. This one hits with every bite!! $10 today only. 718-815-7070

04/17/2026

Fridays are for pizza. 718-815-7070. Also available on every major online ordering platform.

This… This here… This will blow your hair back. This will brighten your day. It’ll change your mood. CANNOLI PINWHEELS!!...
04/10/2026

This… This here… This will blow your hair back. This will brighten your day. It’ll change your mood. CANNOLI PINWHEELS!!!! Soft, pillowy dough, cannoli cream, chocolate chips, and baked to PERFECTION! Then we top it with chocolate syrup and powdered sugar. Every bite is better than the next. 718-815-7070 LIMITED QUANTITIES!!!

PANINIS ARE HERE!!! Lunch Specials, 11-3, 718-815-7070
04/08/2026

PANINIS ARE HERE!!! Lunch Specials, 11-3,
718-815-7070

We are closed today for Easter. Wishing everyone a very Happy Easter. We will be back at it tomorrow serving up all your...
04/05/2026

We are closed today for Easter. Wishing everyone a very Happy Easter. We will be back at it tomorrow serving up all your favorites.

Happy Good Friday. Lent is coming to an end and we have a treat for all those who observe this time of year. Our famous ...
04/03/2026

Happy Good Friday. Lent is coming to an end and we have a treat for all those who observe this time of year. Our famous Seafood Salad!!! 12oz $10 and 16oz $15
718-815-7070

RETURN OF THE MAC!!! Mac & Cheese $6 plain$7 w/ buff chicken $7 w/ pulled pork
04/01/2026

RETURN OF THE MAC!!! Mac & Cheese $6 plain
$7 w/ buff chicken
$7 w/ pulled pork

Pinwheels! Get your Pinwheels! Bbq Chicken just came outta the oven!! Come and Get Em while you can. 718-815-7070
03/31/2026

Pinwheels! Get your Pinwheels! Bbq Chicken just came outta the oven!! Come and Get Em while you can. 718-815-7070

Steam Table Special!!!Beef Stew w: Potatoes & Mixed Veggies. Served over rice $10.Hearty beef stew w/ the perfect amount...
03/31/2026

Steam Table Special!!!
Beef Stew w: Potatoes & Mixed Veggies. Served over rice $10.
Hearty beef stew w/ the perfect amount of spice and kick. Tender and flavorful vegetables really fill and tie this dish together. Comfort food at its finest. 718-815-7070

Pinwheels, Speciality Slices, Regular Slices, Chicken Rolls, Sicilian and Grandma…. A little something for everyone. Not...
03/27/2026

Pinwheels, Speciality Slices, Regular Slices, Chicken Rolls, Sicilian and Grandma…. A little something for everyone. Not to mention a FULL MENU of pizzas, pastas, heros, entrees, wraps and desserts!!! 718-815-7070 and every major online ordering platform

Steam table specials!!! Mac & Cheese and Pulled Pork. Get em together. Get em separate. Either way you can’t go wrong.Ma...
03/25/2026

Steam table specials!!! Mac & Cheese and Pulled Pork. Get em together. Get em separate. Either way you can’t go wrong.
Mac & Cheese $6
Mac & Cheese topped w/ Pulled Pork $7
Pulled Pork on a potato roll $8

718-815-7070

Today in the steam table we got POTATO SKINS!!! These ain’t your ordinary skins, they’re topped w/ MASHED POTATO AND STE...
03/24/2026

Today in the steam table we got POTATO SKINS!!! These ain’t your ordinary skins, they’re topped w/ MASHED POTATO AND STEAK TIPS!!! Then finished with CHIPOTLE MAYO!!
2 pieces per order, $9.
718-815-7070

Today on the counter we have MINI CHEESE RAVIOLI. CHOICE OF VODKA SAUCE OR PESTO!!! $9 per serving. 718-815-7070
03/18/2026

Today on the counter we have MINI CHEESE RAVIOLI. CHOICE OF VODKA SAUCE OR PESTO!!! $9 per serving. 718-815-7070

Happy St Patrick’s Day!!! Corned Beef & Cabbage while it lasts. 718-815-7070.
03/17/2026

Happy St Patrick’s Day!!! Corned Beef & Cabbage while it lasts. 718-815-7070.

We got some goods today on the counter!!!-Mac & Cheese Riceballs $2 each or 3 for $5-Chicken France Riceballs $2 each or...
03/04/2026

We got some goods today on the counter!!!
-Mac & Cheese Riceballs $2 each or 3 for $5
-Chicken France Riceballs $2 each or 3 for $5
-Mac & Cheese w/ Buffalo Chicken $7

Get it while you can, available today on the counter.
718-815-7070 FREE DELIVERY

Also available to place orders on Uber, DoorDash, Slice, WhereYouEat and every major online ordering platform

Is it a cupcake? Is it a muffin? Call it what you want, either it’s a slice of THANKSGIVING heaven!! Mashed potato, turk...
03/03/2026

Is it a cupcake? Is it a muffin? Call it what you want, either it’s a slice of THANKSGIVING heaven!! Mashed potato, turkey breast and stuffing combine to form this little bite of thanksgiving. Available today only, $4
718-815-7070

HOT HONEY PEPPERONI PINWHEELS!!! Perfect combo of sweet, spicy and savory. $4 each, get em while you can! 718-815-7070
03/02/2026

HOT HONEY PEPPERONI PINWHEELS!!! Perfect combo of sweet, spicy and savory. $4 each, get em while you can!
718-815-7070

We are open and delivering all day!! 718-815-7070 and every major online ordering platform
02/24/2026

We are open and delivering all day!! 718-815-7070 and every major online ordering platform

Address

1250 Hylan Boulevard
Staten Island, NY
10305

To get to the location on Hylan Boulevard in New York, you can take public transport by taking the S78 bus and getting off at the Hylan Boulevard/Ridgecrest Avenue stop. Alternatively, if driving, take the I-278 W highway and exit at Hylan Boulevard. There is parking available along Hylan Boulevard or neighboring streets.

Opening Hours

Monday 8am - 10:30pm
Tuesday 8am - 10:30pm
Wednesday 8am - 10:30pm
Thursday 8am - 10:30pm
Friday 8am - 11pm
Saturday 8am - 11pm
Sunday 10:30am - 10:30pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Brooklyn's Finest Pizza & Restaurant posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category

What people say

Brooklyn's Finest Pizza & Restaurant is a must-visit for anyone looking to indulge in authentic Brooklyn-style cuisine. The owner, Joseph Compitello, has brought his love of food from his childhood in Park Slope to Staten Island. The menu boasts a wide variety of local Brooklyn favorites, including panelles and egg creams, which are sure to satisfy any craving. The restaurant's cozy atmosphere and friendly staff make it the perfect spot for a casual night out with friends or family. Whether you're in the mood for pizza or one of their delicious home-style dishes, Brooklyn's Finest Pizza & Restaurant is sure to leave you feeling satisfied and wanting more. Don't miss out on this gem located on Hylan Boulevard!

Claim ownership or report listing