Clicky

Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria

Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria Angelos Coal Oven Pizzeria, a fourth generation pizza-making family dynasty, continues the tradition of authentic Italian pizza started by the original Angelo in the late 1930s. With a commitment to using fresh ingredients and achieving a blackened, crisp crust, Angelos Pizza on W 57th Street in New York City is highly rated for their excellent and exquisite pizza.

Recent social media posts

Pull up hungry. Leave obsessed.From the first slice to the last forkful
05/26/2026

Pull up hungry. Leave obsessed.

From the first slice to the last forkful

One bite changed everything  ⭐🍕Rated 9.3 by . If you haven’t had a slice yet… what are you waiting for?
05/22/2026

One bite changed everything

⭐🍕Rated 9.3 by . If you haven’t had a slice yet… what are you waiting for?

Soft, silky & perfectly sweetThe pizza may bring you in… but this cheesecake keeps you coming back
05/20/2026

Soft, silky & perfectly sweet

The pizza may bring you in… but this cheesecake keeps you coming back

05/19/2026
Twirl into comfort 🍝 Fresh pasta, rich sauce, and the perfect bite every time
05/19/2026

Twirl into comfort 🍝 Fresh pasta, rich sauce, and the perfect bite every time

Full pies, warm bread, and a table made for sharing🙌🏼Join us today  🌟Rated 9.3 by Dave Portnoy One Bite Pizza Review
03/07/2026

Full pies, warm bread, and a table made for sharing🙌🏼

Join us today
🌟Rated 9.3 by Dave Portnoy One Bite Pizza Review

Big slice energy  📍117 W 57th Street ⭐Rated 9.3 by Dave Portnoy!
02/20/2026

Big slice energy

📍117 W 57th Street
⭐Rated 9.3 by Dave Portnoy!

Come in & enjoy what Dave Portnoy rated 9.3 on his One Bite Pizza Review 😋One Bite, and you're in love   📍117 W 57th St,...
02/10/2026

Come in & enjoy what Dave Portnoy rated 9.3 on his One Bite Pizza Review 😋

One Bite, and you're in love
📍117 W 57th St, New York, NY 10019

Pizza nights > EverythingEnjoy Love at first slice  📍117 W 57th St, New York, NY 10019
02/08/2026

Pizza nights > Everything

Enjoy Love at first slice
📍117 W 57th St, New York, NY 10019

Sunday sauce energy. Any day of the week  🍝Tag who’s ordering this with you
01/20/2026

Sunday sauce energy. Any day of the week

🍝Tag who’s ordering this with you

Elevated comfort food where flavor comes first  📍117 W 57th Street
01/15/2026

Elevated comfort food where flavor comes first


📍117 W 57th Street

One table, too many favorites 😋Visit us today
12/30/2025

One table, too many favorites 😋

Visit us today

End your dinner on a high note with our desserts🍴 📍117 W 57th Street
12/26/2025

End your dinner on a high note with our desserts🍴


📍117 W 57th Street

This is your sign to order the pizza with a side of pasta 😉 Visit us today  📍117 W 57th Street ⭐Rated 9.3 by Dave Portno...
12/24/2025

This is your sign to order the pizza with a side of pasta 😉

Visit us today
📍117 W 57th Street
⭐Rated 9.3 by Dave Portnoy

Family recipes, fresh ingredients & unforgettable tasteJoin us tonight  📍117 W 57th Street ⭐Rated 9.3 by Dave Portnoy
12/09/2025

Family recipes, fresh ingredients & unforgettable taste

Join us tonight
📍117 W 57th Street
⭐Rated 9.3 by Dave Portnoy

Fresh, comforting, and made to be devoured 😋Visit us today  117 W 57th St, New York, NY 10019⭐Rated 9.3 by Dave Portnoy
12/04/2025

Fresh, comforting, and made to be devoured 😋

Visit us today
117 W 57th St, New York, NY 10019
⭐Rated 9.3 by Dave Portnoy

Never too early for dessert😋 Come in and enjoy today  📍117 W 57th Street Find us on
11/21/2025

Never too early for dessert😋

Come in and enjoy today
📍117 W 57th Street
Find us on

Address

117 W 57th Street
New York, NY
10001

Located on W 57th Street in New York, this destination is easily accessible by public transport. You can take the subway and get off at the 57th Street station, which is just a short walk away. Alternatively, you can also take a bus that stops near W 57th Street.

If you prefer to drive, there are parking garages available in the vicinity where you can park your vehicle for a fee. Be sure to check for any parking restrictions or regulations in the area before leaving your car.

Overall, getting to W 57th Street in New York is convenient whether you choose to use public transport or drive yourself.

Opening Hours

Monday 11:30am - 10pm
Tuesday 11:30am - 10pm
Wednesday 11:30am - 10pm
Thursday 11:30am - 10pm
Friday 11:30am - 11pm
Saturday 11:30am - 11pm
Sunday 11:30am - 10pm

Telephone

+1 212-333-4333

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria:

Share

Category

What people say

Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria on W 57th Street in New York City is a true gem for pizza lovers. This family-owned establishment carries on a rich tradition of pizza-making that dates back to the late 1930s when the original Angelo first arrived in the country. With a dedication to authentic Italian pizza, Angelo's has become a beloved spot for those seeking a truly exceptional dining experience.

What sets Angelo's apart is their commitment to quality and tradition. The crust is perfectly blackened and crisp, just as Angelo himself insisted upon. Each pizza is crafted with fresh mozzarella and tomatoes, ensuring that every bite bursts with flavor. This attention to detail and passion for authentic pizza-making has been passed down through four generations of the family, resulting in an unparalleled level of excellence.

It's no wonder that Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria has earned a stellar rating of 9.3 from Bar Stool Sports. The dedication to quality and the genuine love for their craft shines through in every dish served at this establishment. Whether you're a longtime fan of traditional Italian pizza or simply looking for a delicious meal, Angelo's is sure to impress with their exquisite pizzas.

For an unforgettable dining experience that pays homage to the roots of Italian pizza-making, look no further than Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria on W 57th Street. Prepare to be delighted by the flavors and traditions that have been cherished by generations of this remarkable family dynasty.

Claim ownership or report listing