Recent social media posts
05/23/2026
🇺🇸 Sweet treats for your Memorial Day weekend 🇺🇸
Celebrate, remember, and share something delicious with the people you love ❤️🤍💙
🍪 2lb Cookie Tray — perfect for the whole party
🎁 1.5lb Cookie Tin — ready for gifting
Available now at Cookie Jar!
Remember. Honor. Celebrate. 🇺🇸
05/21/2026
Your new favorite Staten Island cookie spot
🍪✨
05/14/2026
Graduation season is here 🎓🍪
Make your party favors extra sweet with custom cookie boxes from Cookie Jar ✨ Choose your own box, ribbon, writing, and cookies to match your celebration perfectly 💖
05/14/2026
Graduation season is here 🎓🍪
Make your party favors extra sweet with custom cookie boxes from Cookie Jar ✨ Choose your own box, ribbon, writing, and cookies to match your celebration perfectly 💖
05/10/2026
From our Cookie Jar family to yours — Happy Mother’s Day 💖
05/09/2026
The perfect Mother’s Day treat from the cookie jar — because moms deserve something as sweet as they are 🌷✨
05/04/2026
Raspberry coconut everything ❤️🥥
Our iced latte paired with our fresh-baked cookies - the combo you didn’t know you needed
Sweet, creamy, a little fruity… and gone way too fast
Come get yours today😋
04/17/2026
Sweet little treats, perfectly wrapped for your special day 💕✨
Custom party favors that leave a lasting impression 🎀🍪
Call (718)-448-3500 or stop in at 1226 Forest Ave to create your own!
04/11/2026
Sweet, personal, and made just for your special moments 💝🍪
From “she said yes” to “congrats grad,” our customizable cookie boxes make every event unforgettable.
Call us for any inquiries or stop in to order your own at 1226 Forest Ave 📞✨
04/10/2026
Our delicious little cookies, baked to perfection✨🍪
Come treat yourself at Cake Chef & Cookie Jar
03/03/2026
Red velvet lovers, this one’s for you ❤️🍪
Our Red Velvet cookies are soft and packed with white chocolate chips.
02/27/2026
Caterers. Event Planners. Restaurants. 🍪
Your dessert table just found its supplier.
We specialize in premium wholesale small cookie assortments — over 100 varieties, available loose or arranged on trays. From 5 lbs to 500 lbs, we scale with your event.
Reliable. High-quality. Ready when you are.
📍 Serving NYC/NJ
📞 Call or text (718) 909-3533
02/25/2026
Calling all caterers, party planners & restaurants 🍪
We supply high-quality wholesale small cookie assortments — available loose or beautifully arranged on trays.
Perfect for catering, dessert tables, and events of any size.
📍 Serving NYC/NJ
📞 Call or text (718) 909-3533
02/11/2026
“The perfect rainbow cookie doesn’t exis—” 💗❤️
Valentine’s Day rainbow cookies are here for a limited time!
02/09/2026
The sweetest Valentine’s gifts are here 💘
Cookie boxes, cookie buckets, chocolate-dipped strawberries & more — all available for preorder now.
📅 Feb 9–Feb 14 pickups/deliveries
📲 Order through the CakeChef app
02/08/2026
Game Day Sweet Spot! 🍪🏈
We’re open 9 AM–6 PM today for Super Bowl Sunday! Grab our festive 2 lb cookie trays and score big with Seahawks & Patriots logo cookies — perfect for your watch party! 🎉
02/05/2026
🏈🍪 Whether you’re cheering for the Seahawks or the Patriots, we’ve got your Super Bowl cookie fix!
Grab team logo cookies and/or 2 lb assorted cookie trays— perfect for game day!🏈
Available Saturday & Sunday 🤩
01/29/2026
Cookies > flowers 🍪💘
Valentine’s Day cookie boxes are now available to pre-order in the Cakechef app! Choose your box and get about 1 lb of assorted cookies.
01/21/2026
🧋✨ NEW promo starts TODAY! All bubble tea is BUY 1, GET 1 FREE at Cookie Jar Forest through February 4th!
Address
1226 Forest Avenue
Staten Island, NY
10310
To reach the bakery and cupcake shop at Forest Avenue in New York, you can take the public transport by getting off at the nearest subway station and walking for a few minutes. Alternatively, you can drive down to Forest Avenue and park your vehicle at any of the nearby parking lots or on-street parking spots.
Opening Hours
| Monday |
10am - 7pm |
| Tuesday |
10am - 7pm |
| Wednesday |
10am - 7pm |
| Thursday |
10am - 7pm |
| Friday |
9am - 8pm |
| Saturday |
9am - 8pm |
| Sunday |
9am - 5pm |
Alerts
Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Cookie Jar posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
Contact The Business
Send a message to Cookie Jar:
What people say
Cookie Jar on Forest Avenue is a must-visit bakery and cupcake shop for anyone with a sweet tooth. With over 140 different cookies available daily, there is something for everyone to enjoy. Each recipe is unique and developed by the Master Baker Cakechef, ensuring that every bite is satisfyingly delicious. The dedication to quality is evident in every cookie, making it worth the calories. In addition to their impressive selection of cookies, Cookie Jar also offers eight different flavors of delectable cupcakes. Be sure to check out their website and Instagram page for mouth-watering pictures of their treats. Don't miss out on this gem of a bakery!
