Redemption Coffee

Home
Staten Island
Forest Avenue
Redemption Coffee

Redemption Coffee, also known as The Mustard Seed, is a cafe located on Forest Avenue. They offer a variety of great coffee drinks, including the house-brewed and nicely spiced Masala Chai with the option to add a shot of espresso. They are now open earlier on weekdays starting at 7 am and offer a FREE DONUT special from 7-9 am. Try any drink with their house-made syrups!

Recent social media posts

06/12/2026

BOARDWALK LEMONADE:
our house-made lemonade, refreshingly tart, sweet and sour. perfect for the summer weather 🍋

06/05/2026

COCONUT PANDAN: smooth & silky coconut, nutty & floral pandan.
🥥🌏

taste of Southeast Asia. or like Cap'n Crunch.. he probably sailed there. 🤷🏽‍♂️⚓

drink recommendation:
-espresso/cold brew soda w/ black walnut bitters
-cold brew
-matcha latte or matcha soda
-iced jasmine or green tea
-iced chai

06/02/2026

SCANDINAVIAN CITRUS: bright and zesty lemon, creamy vanilla, spicy/herbal licorice.

some say it tastes like a lemon jelly bean... not the intention, but whatever lights your way north 🍋🧭

drink recommendation:
-espresso soda w/ Peychaud's or to***co bitters
-cold brew or cold brew soda
-matcha latte or matcha soda
-iced peppermint or green tea
-hot coffee/tea

05/01/2026

ELDERFLOWER, CUCUMBER & JUNIPER:
creamy-floral, sweet-crispy, sharp-citrusy

our gin-inspired syrup Mother's Day and ALL OF MAY. because, at Redemption Coffee, we make beverages and flavors for adults.

drink recommendation:
-espresso tonic w/ angostura bitters
-cold brew
-iced tea
-hot coffee/tea

04/23/2026

Seasonal Syrup: MINT JULEP 🏇🏼👒🥃
cool, refreshing mint toned down with spicy/boozy notes of rye and bourbon whiskey, dashed with Angostura bitters.

just in time for the Kentucky Derby,

NON ALCOHOLIC.

04/14/2026

04/06/2026

6 O'Clock PM
Mondays thru Thursdays we are now open later

03/02/2026

NEW ITEM: JAPANESE EGG SALAD BUN
luscious egg salad, made with Japanese mayonnaise, served with dijon mustard on a buttered brioche roll.

Address

572 Forest Avenue
Staten Island, NY
10310

To reach Forest Avenue in New York, one can take the subway and exit at the Forest Avenue Station. From there, walk north towards the intersection of Forest Avenue and Myrtle Avenue. Alternatively, if driving, take Exit 22A from I-278 W and turn right onto Forest Avenue. Limited street parking is available nearby or there are several parking lots within a few blocks of Forest Avenue.

Opening Hours

Monday	7am - 4pm
Tuesday	7am - 4pm
Wednesday	7am - 4pm
Thursday	7am - 4pm
Friday	7am - 4pm
Saturday	8am - 4pm

Telephone

+17186821060

Website

facebook.com

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Redemption Coffee posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

What people say

Redemption Coffee, located on Forest Avenue in New York, is a must-visit café for coffee lovers. With its recent announcement of extended hours, customers can now enjoy their delicious drinks and food until 7 pm on weekdays and until 4 pm on Saturdays. The café also shows appreciation for teachers by offering them a 15% discount on purchases. One of their standout drinks is the Masala Chai, which is perfectly brewed with a blend of spices and your choice of milk. And if you're an early bird, Redemption Coffee has got you covered with their free donut special between 7 am and 9 am from Monday to Friday. With its welcoming atmosphere and excellent service, Redemption Coffee is definitely worth checking out.

Claim ownership or report listing