Otra Casita Mexicana

Otra Casita Mexicana Otra Casita Mexicana is a Mexican restaurant located on Fresh Pond Road. They offer a variety of delicious dishes, including seafood pappardelle and burritos. The restaurant also hosts special events such as Valen-Tini Night for Valentine's Day. Come and celebrate with your loved one at Otra Casita Mexicana.

Recent social media posts

Since the adults had their sip & paint, it’s not time to do something for the kiddos! Come and join us October 29th for ...
10/04/2026

Since the adults had their sip & paint, it’s not time to do something for the kiddos! Come and join us October 29th for an amazing Halloween theme event! Children will be painting their own artwork with the help of an instructor. Dress them up for Halloween and come have fun! Tickets have to be purchased in advance as spots are limited!

Fall is almost here - which means another Sip & Paint night will be taking place at Otra Casita 🍂🤎 Please book your spot...
09/16/2026

Fall is almost here - which means another Sip & Paint night will be taking place at Otra Casita 🍂🤎 Please book your spots as soon as possible - don’t wait till the last minute. Call or text (347)641-1272 to reserve! September 25th at 7pm! Hope to see you there!

September specials - The Black Widow 🍂 Wickedly delicious cocktail with blackberries and vodka. If you know, you know. ...
09/08/2026

September specials - The Black Widow 🍂 Wickedly delicious cocktail with blackberries and vodka. If you know, you know.

Another year, another A 👏 Thank you to our team for the dedication and effort!
08/12/2026

Another year, another A 👏 Thank you to our team for the dedication and effort!

Decision fatigue? Solved. We’re trying every taco on the menu! Which one is your favorite?! 🌮
07/03/2026

Decision fatigue? Solved. We’re trying every taco on the menu! Which one is your favorite?! 🌮

This Father’s Day, treat your dad right — margaritas for the win, b**r for the legend. Cheers! **r
06/21/2026

This Father’s Day, treat your dad right — margaritas for the win, b**r for the legend. Cheers! **r

Salad for the win; Margarita for the grin 🥗🍹
06/13/2026

Salad for the win; Margarita for the grin 🥗🍹

Sip & Paint Night 🎨 Unplug, unwind, and unleash your inner artist! Join us for a fun, relaxed evening of painting, sippi...
05/13/2026

Sip & Paint Night 🎨 Unplug, unwind, and unleash your inner artist! Join us for a fun, relaxed evening of painting, sipping, and good vibes! Friday, May 29th @ 7PM. Reserve your seat!

Treat her to bold flavors, fresh ingredients, and a table full of love. From our creamy shrimp-filled avocados to handcr...
05/08/2026

Treat her to bold flavors, fresh ingredients, and a table full of love. From our creamy shrimp-filled avocados to handcrafted cocktails and all the festive bites in between — make this Mother’s Day one she’ll never forget. 💐

Address

66-21 Fresh Pond Road
Ridgewood, NY
11385

To reach Fresh Pond Road in New York by public transport, take the subway and get off at the M train station. From there, take a bus heading towards Fresh Pond Road. Alternatively, you can reach Fresh Pond Road by driving and park your car along the street. Please note that parking regulations vary on different parts of Fresh Pond Road, so make sure to check posted signs for parking instructions.

Opening Hours

Monday 12pm - 10pm
Tuesday 12pm - 10pm
Wednesday 12pm - 10pm
Thursday 12pm - 11pm
Friday 12pm - 11pm
Saturday 10:30am - 11pm
Sunday 10:30am - 11pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Otra Casita Mexicana posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category

What people say

Mexican restaurants are known for their vibrant and flavorful dishes that are sure to satisfy any craving. Otra Casita Mexicana on Fresh Pond Road in New York is no exception. This Mexican restaurant has captured the hearts of many with its delicious food and festive atmosphere.

One thing that sets Otra Casita Mexicana apart from other Mexican restaurants is their attention to detail when it comes to their dishes. From the Seafood Pappardelle Special to their famous Margaritas, each dish is carefully crafted with fresh ingredients and bursting with flavor.

In addition to their amazing food, Otra Casita Mexicana also offers a lively atmosphere that's perfect for any occasion. Whether you're looking for a romantic night out or a fun evening with friends, this restaurant has got you covered. They even have special events like Valen-Tini Night where you can enjoy great music and drinks with your loved one.

Overall, Otra Casita Mexicana is a must-visit for anyone who loves Mexican cuisine. With its delicious food, festive atmosphere, and friendly staff, it's no wonder why this restaurant has become a favorite among locals and visitors alike.