Clicky

AJ’s Specialty Cheesecakes

AJ’s Specialty Cheesecakes AJ's Specialty Cheesecakes is a dessert shop and restaurant located on Huguenot Avenue, offering over 40 different types of cheesecakes. Pickup is by appointment only, and they are known for their gluten-free options as well as their creative flavors featuring Baileys liqueurs. Try the seasonal S'mores or Boozy Halloween cheesecake, or indulge in a classic like the Baileys Chocolate Espresso Cheesecake.
(205)

Recent social media posts

Good evening. We are fully booked from now until December 24th. We will be closed on Christmas Day. Orders are being acc...
12/16/2024

Good evening. We are fully booked from now until December 24th. We will be closed on Christmas Day. Orders are being accepted from December 26th, on. Availability is still available for NYE. Thank you everyone that ordered and continue to support this business. Happy Holidays!!

Our Christmas Menu is up and ready for orders for the holiday season!! Don’t delay as orders fill up fairly quick. Our n...
12/03/2024

Our Christmas Menu is up and ready for orders for the holiday season!! Don’t delay as orders fill up fairly quick. Our newest flavor which is also on the menu is Dulce de Leche. Dulce de Leche infused cheesecake on a chocolate graham cracker crust and topped with homemade, whipped Dulce de Leche mousse. Please be advised that we will be closed from 12/5-12/9 for a family function. We look forward to making you delicious cakes this holiday season. Happy Holidays!!

Sorry, we are fully booked for Thanksgiving week! Thank you to all who ordered. We look forward to providing you with am...
11/14/2024

Sorry, we are fully booked for Thanksgiving week! Thank you to all who ordered. We look forward to providing you with amazing cakes this holiday. We are accepting orders for now until Saturday November 23rd. Additional orders starting up on Saturday November 30th may be placed as well. Thank you.

Our Thanksgiving menu is now available for orders from 11/22-11/27. Pickups are available also for late pickup on Thanks...
11/04/2024

Our Thanksgiving menu is now available for orders from 11/22-11/27. Pickups are available also for late pickup on Thanksgiving Eve. We look forward to providing you amazing desserts!!

It’s that time of year again. Pumpkin Cheesecake is back on the menu at AJ’s Specialty Cheesecakes. Topped with our home...
09/13/2024

It’s that time of year again. Pumpkin Cheesecake is back on the menu at AJ’s Specialty Cheesecakes. Topped with our homemade Pumpkin spice whipped cream. Available starting 9/18 until Thanksgiving!

🚨 We have 2 six inch ultimate Oreo cheesecakes available for pick up today!!!!! 🚨 pm for more details
08/17/2024

🚨 We have 2 six inch ultimate Oreo cheesecakes available for pick up today!!!!! 🚨 pm for more details

I have two tickets to MetLife stadium Section 142 row 8 for tomorrow Friday July 19th.
07/19/2024

I have two tickets to MetLife stadium
Section 142 row 8 for tomorrow Friday July 19th.

Highly recommend Owen and Liam. We used them today, and they did An amazing job. And the front of our house is not an ea...
06/01/2024

Highly recommend Owen and Liam. We used them today, and they did An amazing job. And the front of our house is not an easy task. Cara Mia

There is A LOT going on here at AJ’s. We have TWO new cakes and our EASTER menu is available.🚨 Introducing the newest me...
03/10/2024

There is A LOT going on here at AJ’s. We have TWO new cakes and our EASTER menu is available.

🚨 Introducing the newest members to our cheesecakes list 🚨

Banana Cheesecake- Banana flavored cheesecake on top of a vanilla cookie wafer crust. Topped with homemade banana flavored whipped cream, banana slices and vanilla wafer crumbles

Carrot Cake Cheesecake-plain cheesecake on a homemade carrot cake crust. Topped with our homemade whipped cream cheese frosting and toasted walnuts

🚨 cheesecake mini sale 🚨 We have three  packs of plain mini cheesecakes for pick up today.12 in each pack. PM to pick up...
02/22/2024

🚨 cheesecake mini sale 🚨
We have three packs of plain mini cheesecakes for pick up today.
12 in each pack.

PM to pick up yours!!!

Address

Huguenot Avenue, Staten Island
New York, NY
10312

To get to the location on Huguenot Avenue in New York, you can take the Staten Island Railway and get off at the Huguenot station. From there, walk south on Huguenot Avenue for about 10 minutes until you reach your destination.

If you prefer to drive, take the West Shore Expressway to exit 5 towards Bloomingdale Road. Turn left onto Bloomingdale Road and continue straight until you reach Huguenot Avenue. Turn right onto Huguenot Avenue and continue for about a mile until you reach your destination.

There is street parking available near the location, but it may be limited during peak hours. Alternatively, there is a parking lot located nearby on Sharrotts Road that offers free parking.

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 6pm
Tuesday 9am - 6pm
Wednesday 9am - 6pm
Thursday 9am - 6pm
Friday 9am - 6pm
Saturday 9am - 6pm
Sunday 9am - 6pm

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when AJ’s Specialty Cheesecakes posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Share

Category

What people say

AJ’s Specialty Cheesecakes is a dessert shop and restaurant located on Huguenot Avenue in New York. This cheesecake haven offers over 40 different types of cheesecakes, each one more delicious than the last. The best part? You can pick up your favorite flavor by appointment only, ensuring that you get the freshest and most delectable treat possible.

One of their newest flavors, the Baileys Chocolate Espresso Cheesecake, is a must-try for coffee lovers. This chocolate espresso flavored cheesecake is infused with Baileys Espresso Liqueur and sits on top of a chocolate espresso graham cracker crust. It's then topped with homemade Baileys Chocolate Espresso whipped cream and a chocolate drizzle. And if you're not into alcohol, they also offer a non-alcoholic version.

If you're gluten-free, AJ’s Specialty Cheesecakes has got you covered too! They recently announced that they offer gluten-free options as well.

And let's not forget about their seasonal flavors! Their S’mores cheesecake infused with Baileys S’mores liquor is perfect for fall and Halloween festivities. It's filled with marshmallow filling and chopped Hershey Bars, topped with Hersheys & Baileys S’mores infused Chocolate ganache and toasted marshmallows.

Overall, AJ’s Specialty Cheesecakes is a must-visit for anyone looking for a sweet treat in New York City. With so many flavors to choose from (including funfetti Halloween cheesecake!), there's something for everyone at this dessert haven.

Claim ownership or report listing