Bittersweet Bake Shoppe

Bittersweet Bake Shoppe Bittersweet Bake Shoppe is a bakery and cupcake shop located on Arthur Kill Road, offering a variety of nut-free and gluten-free options for desserts suitable for any occasion. In addition to their regular menu items, they also offer seasonal treats such as Easter baskets filled with cookies, peeps, and plastic eggs with surprises inside. Their personalized chick boxes make the perfect Easter basket add-on as well. Don't miss out on their flash sales or specialty items such as hand-painted cardinal cakes or vanilla buttercream candles - perfect gifts for any occasion!

Recent social media posts

Witch, please! 👻🎃🩷🕸️
10/21/2026

Witch, please! 👻🎃🩷🕸️

Something blue🩵💍
10/20/2026

Something blue🩵💍

Tomorrow is the LAST DAY to order for Halloween!!
10/15/2026

Tomorrow is the LAST DAY to order for Halloween!!

Last chance to order for Halloween!! Our order form will close on FRIDAY!!! We will not be accepting anymore orders past...
10/13/2026

Last chance to order for Halloween!! Our order form will close on FRIDAY!!! We will not be accepting anymore orders past Friday. If you are looking to reserve your cookies, please do so ASAP🎃

Join our team✨ 🫶🏻Please email your resume and pictures of your past work to our email, bittersweetbakeshoppesi@gmail.com
10/11/2026

Join our team✨

🫶🏻Please email your resume and pictures of your past work to our email, [email protected]

Did you remember to order for Halloween? Orders will be closing next week! Don’t wait!!100% peanut and tree nut free fac...
10/11/2026

Did you remember to order for Halloween? Orders will be closing next week! Don’t wait!!

100% peanut and tree nut free facility

Stop in today for a sweet treat 🤤🎃🧁• 1- 6 pack vanilla cupcakes with cinnamon sugar buttercream and apple pie spread cen...
10/09/2026

Stop in today for a sweet treat 🤤🎃🧁

• 1- 6 pack vanilla cupcakes with cinnamon sugar buttercream and apple pie spread center $15
• 1- 6 pack cinnamon toast crunch cupcakes with cinnamon sugar buttercream and apple pie spread center $15
• 4 single vanilla cupcake with cinnamon sugar buttercream and apple pie spread center $2.50 each
• 4 DIY kits $12 each
• mini “pillsbury cookie” packs includes 6 cookies $12 eaxh
• pumpkin snickerdoodle cookies 3 per pack $8
•jumbo biscoff cookies $6 each
•pumpkin Sammie’s $6 each

Open today 10am- 5pm
Saturday 10am-3pm
CLOSED SUNDAY AND MONDAY

The sweetest little details 🍋🎀✨
10/07/2026

The sweetest little details 🍋🎀✨

10/06/2026
Wild one 🍃🌴🐘🦒🦓🦧
10/05/2026

Wild one 🍃🌴🐘🦒🦓🦧

Feeling spooky? Don’t wait to order your Halloween options! 🎃100% peanut and treenut free facility!
10/04/2026

Feeling spooky? Don’t wait to order your Halloween options!

🎃100% peanut and treenut free facility!

We’re excited to announce that our Halloween cookies are now available for order! They are perfect for school parties or...
10/03/2026

We’re excited to announce that our Halloween cookies are now available for order!

They are perfect for school parties or just because, and you can feel good knowing they're 100% peanut- and tree-nut-free. With limited availability, order soon to enjoy a sweet, safe Halloween celebration!

Click here for an update from Bittersweet Bake Shoppe!

Fairy first birthday ✨🍄🧚🏻🌼
09/30/2026

Fairy first birthday ✨🍄🧚🏻🌼

Address

4275 Arthur Kill Road
New York, NY
10309

To get to the location on Arthur Kill Road in New York, visitors can take the S78 bus to the stop at Arthur Kill Road and Richmond Avenue. Alternatively, they can drive and park in the lot near the intersection of Arthur Kill Road and Richmond Avenue.

Opening Hours

Tuesday 10am - 5pm
Wednesday 10am - 5pm
Thursday 10am - 5pm
Friday 10am - 5pm
Saturday 10am - 3pm
Sunday 10am - 1pm

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Bittersweet Bake Shoppe posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Bittersweet Bake Shoppe:

Share

What people say

Bittersweet Bake Shoppe is a delightful bakery and cupcake shop located on Arthur Kill Road in New York. This bakery offers desserts for any occasion, making it the perfect place to satisfy your sweet tooth cravings. One of the best things about Bittersweet Bake Shoppe is that they have a nut-free facility, ensuring that everyone can enjoy their delicious treats without any worries.

Their social media posts show how much they care about their customers and appreciate their support. They offer special sets for Father's Day and Mother's Day, as well as options for Teacher Appreciation Week. Their fairy tale sweet 16 cake looks magical and their cupcake bouquets are a must-try.

Bittersweet Bake Shoppe also offers new flavors such as cookie dough, vanilla with rainbow sprinkles, and chocolate with chocolate sprinkles. Their cupcakes come in various packs, including vanilla bean cupcakes with flowers, 1/2 vanilla bean 1/2 cookie dough, 1/2 cookie dough 1/2 chocolate, and more.

Overall, Bittersweet Bake Shoppe is a fantastic bakery that provides high-quality desserts for any occasion. Their attention to detail and commitment to customer satisfaction make them stand out from other bakeries in the area. If you're looking for a place to indulge in some delicious treats, be sure to check out Bittersweet Bake Shoppe!